A woefully underrated horror film. 'When A Stranger Calls' is the essence of great horror cinema. That's a huge statement so I'll back it up. When was the last time you watched a horror film that had horror in it? I'm not talking about suspense, Lord knows that's hard enough to come by but I mean white knuckles, run up the aisle to get out of the theater - horror? Of all the would-be horror films, maybe a dozen have the goods. 'Halloween', 'Jaws', 'The Exorcist', 'Alien' (not 'Aliens', that's fine on suspense but hasn't a clue about horror) all have the essence of what makes a movie going experience terrifying. And so does this little film starring Carol Kane.
I have read a number of reviews that trash this film, complaining that it has a soft middle and no focus and yet, they all agree the opening (and some concede, the closing) sequence(s) are truly terrifying. Well folks, any horror film that can boast a 20 minute sequence that comprises one of the best suspense build ups to a terrifying conclusion goes to the top of my list. The horror film that actually horrifies is as good as it gets, no matter the complaints about a soggy center. (for the record, the middle section is, in my opinion, not as strong as the first and third acts but certainly is watchable and creates a different type of tension)
'When A Stranger Calls' electrified audiences in 1979 because it worked on your nerves, slowly and with disturbing confidence. The score creeps up on you and somehow mimics the audio equivalent to a stomach dropping in dread. The lighting is low key and vignetted creating any number of black shadows for who knows what to hide in. Carol Kane has the face of a silent film star, her large frightened eyes conveying so much that's unspoken. Her building hysteria is timed perfectly. I've never seen a film where audience and lead actor are in such sync.
For these reasons and for having probably one of the best lines ever in a horror film, 'have you checked the children?' - 'When A Stranger Calls' deserves to be included in the top horror films of all time.