This show is confused As a fan of mythology, I adore any show involving the supernatural in modern times. However, Lost Girl is very confused on what it wants to be. Is it a show that just wants to get HBO's attention with its gratuitous sex scenes and stages of undress for the heroines? Is it a genuine grim and gritty update to Charmed or Buffy? Is it a half-baked comedy that features sex jokes as the mainstay of humor? The answer is, it tries to be all of the above and fails at all of them. The first season is OK, with a few nitpicks about the names of the mythological creatures. The second season gets worse with a few more visible issues though and dumb character life-decisions and development. IE, more HBO-wannabe sex scenes for the sake of sex scenes, characters that have outlived their purposes and flat character development. Bo stops being just a competent heroine and becomes an unstoppable Mary Sue that suffers no negative repercussions for her actions and can even take down the leader of the Dark Fae with no effort who I think would be a tad more resistant her orgasm powers.
Then comes the third season and it is bizarre and something I could no longer watch. The addition to Tamsin is a wasted in this role Rachel Skarsten of Birds of Prey fame. Who has improved in acting and beauty over the years and doesn't deserve the entitled bitch character of this show. The show itself is like the exaggerated grim and grittiness of the 90s with the casual sex of the 70s and the outright insanity of the Silver Age of Comics in the 60s. It is no longer the passable show about urban fantasy beings but basically Tarot: Witch of the Black Rose The TV show mixed with Beautiful Creatures.
Overall go ahead and watch it, but don't expect it to be good or memorable. Also if you want good sex scenes get HBO because this show sure as hell wants to be on it so badly.