A wholesome review of Season 8 I, like most (reasonable) fans, was fairly reserved in my criticisms of this season as it was unfolding. I didn't think it would be fair to judge it before it had ended, given that things could be further developed/explained in later episodes (e.g. everyone complaining that Ghost didn't get petted by Jon in episode 4 - you can all shut up now). However, now that the show has come to a close, the season as a whole can be reviewed.
This season started off strong: episode 1 was more or less well-received, and successfully set the scene for the coming episodes. It ended effectively with a scene of sheer horror, foreshadowing the arrival of the Night King at Winterfell.
Episode 2 - to my, and everyone else's, surprise - seemed to be more of the same as episode 1. There was lots of dialogue and there were some very character-heavy moments. This is not a bad thing. If you rewatch previous Game of Thrones seasons - especially the earlier ones - they were largely dominated by such conversations. That being said, the specifics of episodes 1 and 2 unfold such that we are led to believe that we are seeing many of our beloved characters for the last time; indeed, in the "Inside the Episode", Dan & Dave (the showrunners) even alluded to this. The episode was beautifully done, but in retrospect I feel cheated (that feeling is, in essence, how I feel about the season overall).
This is because in episode 3 (which, to be clear, is a phenomenal episode) all of the characters we believed we were seeing for the final time shrugged off death - literally, death - as if it was nothing. We were fooled several times during the episode and led to believe that our favourites were in real danger, when they were not. I don't think I'll be able to watch this episode again without screaming at the TV: "YOU SHOULD BE DEAD!". Grey Worm, Brienne, Jaime, Sam, Sam, Sam (that's not a typo - multiple by 50 and that's how many times Sam should've died that episode), and others.
I do not take issue with Arya killing the Night King. I do, however, take issue with the uselessness of Bran (more on that later), and how quickly the Night King was defeated. I strongly believe that Jon and the NK should have had a duel, which resulted in Jon being defeated. Then, Arya killing the NK would have felt much more impactful, since we would have felt the true odds of the battle and the danger of him and his army in defeating Jon - given he has had the thickest plot armour for quite some time now.
It also feels slightly underwhelming, in retrospect, that the one we were led to believe was the true threat and villain (the NK and his army) was dealt with so swiftly and easily. I know the purpose behind this was to demonstrate that the true threat to our characters has always been one another, but this makes the NK and his army feel like an empty threat (and not just in this season, but will be the case for all seasons when rewatching).
Episode 4 also put me in the minority: I liked the episode. The only thing I could really criticise - in retrospect - is how effective the Scorpions (the big crossbow weapons) seemed against the dragons, yet how useless they were in the following episode.
Episode 5 is another masterpiece - in isolation (pretty much anything Miguel Sapochnik touches turns to gold). I am still torn on Dany's decision, if you can even call it that. I do not believe Dany has it in her to rationally commit genocide. I do, however, believe that given all the loss which she had suffered in such a short time, and consequently how alone she must have been in that moment following so many betrayals, that she could have snapped. But from her scenes in the finale, it appears we are meant to believe that that indeed IS her rationality. This - to me - is unbelievable, as it is incongruous to her behaviour and personality which we have studied for over 7 seasons. To have this "snap" of Dany's character in so few episodes makes it feel incredibly rushed. I look forward to rewatching all seasons of the show (knowing how Dany ends up) and looking for more subtle clues in her development which point to this being inevitable.
And finally, the finale: I've never felt so indifferent in all my life. George R. R. Martin wanted his story to have a bittersweet ending, yet this is almost entirely bitter. There's too much for me to go over, so I'll be sparing. I find it ridiculous that the Stark children apparently win the Westeros lottery: Bran becomes King of the 6 Kingdoms, Sansa becomes Queen in the North, Arya sails off into the sunset, and Jon's life is spared and he gets to live out the rest of his days in the place where he truly belongs. Sorry - what? This isn't right. Bran becoming King - after doing absolutely nothing ever since he fell out that damn window - feels so undeserved. He was useless for the entire season, and contributed nothing - yet he now rules the 6 Kingdoms? It doesn't sit right with me at all, and I can't accept it. Even though there were several scenes which I really liked in the finale and thought were perfect, the episode itself was far from it. I'm not sure what would have been the "perfect" ending, but this surely can't be it.
I cannot complete this review without doing justice to one of the best characters on the show: Cersei Lannister. This season has been an insult to her: she did nothing but drink wine, look out a window, and cry. She deserves so much better (that being said, I do not take issue with the way she died).
To be clear, above I have highlighted a lot of my complaints with the season; these are more or less my only complaints. I actually liked every episode except for the finale, and enjoy most of them in isolation. At the end of the day, this is still better than pretty much anything else on television (except for the finale).
A final note: nobody seems to be paying attention to the fact that George R. R. Martin has co-produced this entire season. D&D are getting all the hate, despite George telling D&D the way his books will end, and overseeing this finale and them putting it together. He cannot escape criticism. Sorry, George, but you had better find a way to wrap your books up far better than this.
All in all, this season has been an unfortunate way to end the best television series of all time. I wish HBO had pushed D&D harder, and demanded more seasons/episodes, so that this finale wouldn't have felt so rushed and unpolished.
It appears Ramsay was right all along: "If you think this has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention."
RIP Daenerys Targaryen; RIP Game of Thrones