Volume I Vs. Volume II After watching Volume I, I decided to continue on to Volume II. One of the major differences is that Volume I is acted out by Young Joe (Stacy Martin) while Volume II is older Joe (Charlotte Gainsbourgh). I found Charlottes performance to be more believable of someone who is a nymphomaniac, which propelled the story to much greater heights than in Volume I. Another comparison of the two is the tone and pacing. Volume I seemed much longer because there is much more symbolism to music, nature, and mathematics brought up by Seligman(Stellan Skarsgaard) when Joe is explaining her childhood and past affairs. Von Trier takes a lot of time in the first half to make random connections to Joe's experiences, some for comedic effect and others that try to connect sexual prowess with nature. For example when Joe loses her virginity the first time to Jerome(Shia Labeouf). Seligman refers to it as the Fibinachi Sequence when Joe explains that Jerome penetrated her 3 times in the vagina and 5 times anally which equals 8. (I know, I couldn't believe they tried to even make this connection the first time I saw it as well.) A better example is how Seligman connects fly fishing to Joe and B's escapades on the train. The connection of reeling in the perfect catch(men), and how its illustrated in the film by Joe and B scouring the different train compartments, going from men who are less reserved to men that are more choosy when it comes to who they sleep with. There are a few other instances like this in Volume I, which is why the pacing is much slower and the tone is bleak. Another reason the pacing is slower is because Volume I spends much more time on introducing the characters that shapes Joe's experiences such as Joes Father(Christian Slater, M(Uma Thurman, Jerome, B(Sophia Kennedy Clark), and Seligman. The pacing and tone of Volume II is much different because it jumps right into the thick of Joe's darkest experiences being a Nymphomaniac. From the very start of Volume II, we the audience are shown that Joe can no longer feel pleasure from sex. Like a drug someone abuses, Joe's tolerance is so high that she has to resort to cheating, threesome, and fetishes in order to feel pleasure herself, this includes being whipped by a man who has no sympathy for how she feels on the inside.( He full on punches her in the face and even calls her "Fido"). We are shown the gravity of Joe's decisions and who they affect, 1. Marcel, Joe and Jerome's baby almost falls off the balcony unattended because Joe is waiting for her fetish appointment. 2. Jerome ends up taking Marcel and leaves Joe. 3. Jerome can't raise Marcel on his own and ends up leaving him in foster care. The Pedophilia Scene definitely stuck in my head as the most disturbing of the film though. The reason i choose to discuss this scene is because it shows us the severity of Joe's addiction and you will know what I mean when you see it for yourself. Each character that Joe interacts with in Volume II whether its K ( the guy who whips and beats her for pleasure, L (Willem Dafoe)~ the man who proposes that Joe run her own loan sharking business by using her own means of sexual persuasion, and P(Mia Goth)~ the girl that Joe takes under her wing. all enable Joe in some way to go further down the rabbit hole. Basically all the scenes in Volume II are either disturbing or violent in someway compared to Volume I, which is why the tone and pacing is much different between the two.
Violence- 3/5- the scenes were Joe is getting beaten and whipped by K for fetish, we see parts of her body bruised and bloody. When she is beaten to the curb, Joe has blood all over her face. And at the end although we don't see it, it is implied and heard that Joe kills Seligman after he tries to sleep with her.(Unbelievable scene)
Language-3/5- A good amount of "F" Bombs, few instances of C***, Sh**, Bi***..etc
Sexuality- 5/5- Altogether I would say out of the 4 hour film there is an hour that have scenes or shots of fetish, penetration, fellatio, pedophilia, full frontal nudity. Some are shot far away/ Some are up close.
Adult Situations- 5/5- This film deals with someone who is a Nymphomaniac, her experiences are disturbing and brutal because many times throughout the film she is chasing a high that becomes harder and harder to get as her tolerance for it increases. The film shows the destructive sides of being a Nymphomaniac( especially as a woman) such as abuse, womanizing, adultery, pedophilia, adoption, putting your addiction above your family and health. *Joe has a good relationship with her father, but not with her mother. Ex. When Joes Father (Christian Slater is on his deathbed, only Joe comes to visit. Joe has resentment towards her mother for not coming to see her dying husband. *There is a scene depicting the consequences of Adultery where M (Uma Thurman confronts Joe and her ex-husband by bringing the children to Joe's apartment. The situation is tense and heartbreaking, as M finds out that Joe doesn't even love M's husband who has just left her and the children. *The scene where Joe is punched in the face a few times by K may also be quite disturbing. *The scene where Joe's plan of trying to kill P's boyfriend fails as the gun is botched, ends up getting beaten to the ground. *The scene at the end of the film may disturb some viewers as well, when Seligman who is asexual,tries to force himself into Joe when she is sleeping.
Overall a pretty interesting film, I give it an 8/10 for good acting, great storytelling, and imagery.