Encanto is a huge disappointment. The premise is pretty great: A family where everyone has magical powers, except one person (the protagonist, Mirabel).
But, that's the end of the good part. The potential that premise sets up is left completely unfulfilled. Everything is _so weak_ about the writing. To state a few examples:
- the reason why the family got their magic is not explored.
- the reason abuelo is killed is not explained
- who killed abuelo is not revealed
The magical powers itself are really weak too. The family could have had some really cool magical powers (the fantastic 4/incredibles, anyone?), but instead they get... "making flowers"? Rain clouds over Pepa's head? (compare that with Storm in X-Men). Even with good superpowers, for example, the shapeshifter (similar to Mystique in X-men), the power is only used to be goofy. The animal talker & Dolores is the only one with a good superpower that is somewhat well-used. Even the mother's superpower (healing others) is not consequential at all.
Even the set up for conflicts is so weak, and the intra-familial relationships are left woefully unexplored.
The movie had great animation, and great potential but ends up being a complete waste of time due to abysmally poor writing.