Taken as a fantasy action piece it's a fun little ride. This is a really nice piece of fantasy, and a lot of attempts to make things easier to explain the little details that just don't mesh. I really enjoyed the idea that (and come on this movie can not be spoiled it has been told) once the ark comes to rest there would not be any wood to build homes with so they would use that and there explains no ark.
Couple little things though: The remaining humans come off the ark with agrarian skills, and knowledge. Why instead of growing the trees does the all mighty not just grow them an ark? Time in this movie is like the water that runs across the globe meandering here and there in what has to be days, not years (the kids never get older during that time) Last one I have to point out, the story plays off evolution as something that happens in a day, but the planet was spinning, (what unit was that measured in) oh, and they come so close to the man ape question it is kind of painful.
Now you take all of that out of this movie, and you have a really great popcorn flick that anyone who likes fantasy action with a kind of alternate earth like Mordor kind of feeling will love. The Angel/Helper/Rockmen creatures are really nicely blended in for the most part, and the ark itself which strangely takes very little of the surrounding forest to build is a marvel in it's construction that would never work, shaped that way it could only ever sink, there was not even any consideration for buoyancy, or balance. Enough picking apart the details, or I would have to go on about little green screen errors.
I really ended up Enjoying myself watching most of this movie, the fantasy that there was an advanced civilization that covered every inch of land, who were all wiped out, and the evidence some how washed away, and the fact that all the animals came way more than 2 by 2, but no one ever points out that they came from nowhere because the cities had taken everything. Sorry there I go again.
To make it simple this movie is like 10,000 BC, (only not supposed to be as far back somehow...) in the liberties that are taken with history, and proof.
My last question, I have to ask though is how did any girls ever grow to have children in that world? They were all just traded for food, so where did all the guys come from?
So yes I do recommend this as a piece of fluff that you can enjoy for the fantasy that it is, and you will be rewarded with some great effects, and a decent story acted by a top notch cast. Your call, but that's how I call it.
Jesse of www.Jesse.ca