It truly is " A New Beginning"! I thought it was a great premiere. It did everything it needed to do. The IMBD score doesn't do it justice. All these ridiculous 1 star reviews.
The character work was great, the dialogue, writing, score, direction, cinematography, and acting, were the best they've had in years. Lauren Cohan and Andrew Lincoln were great as always. And their dialogue together was great. It set up a intriguing season ahead.
All the acting was really good as usual though. It was a very character focused, and zombie focused premiere. It got back to why we loved the show.
The smaller character scenes( mainly the original cast),and the look and feel and how fresh it is, are the best parts I think in the episode. I can't wait until episode 2! It should be a good one.
Maggie's decision to execute Gregory, may start some dialogue within the communities about the rules and what happens if they don't follow them. I agree with Maggie's decision100%, but I think she should have had a vote with the community leaders first. I bet they'd agree. I like how Angela Kang is writing this Maggie and Rick disagreement. These characters will have to choose which side their on. And Daryl has already chose. In the season 8 finale the whole Maggie, Jesus, and Daryl, revenge plot scene was ridiculous and dumb. Making them seem like villains. They respect and love Rick, but they just disagree with Rick's decision to cater to the Saviors and keep Negan alive. They all have different leadership styles. There's no wrong or right way.
Lastly I agree with the decision of not showing Negan in this episode. Next episode he will appear though. We spent 3 seasons with the Saviors and Negan, and this poorly executed war, that people were getting tired. This was a breath of fresh air. It's truly " A New Beginning"!. I encourage all past and present fans to give this season a chance, I know with the departure of Carl, Rick, and even Maggie for a short period of time, it will be hard, but this season is shaping up to be the best in years, with a new and improved Showrunner. Season 7 and 8 may have not been good, but season 9 will be. So please stop hating and nitpicking this season, and be glad that quality is back on The Walking Dead. This episode deserves at least a 8.5 or higher on IMBD, but my personal rating is a 9.2. And that rating could change during rewatches.