tahoematta

I agree with the other reviews on the funny and screwball nature of the film. This genre must never be compared to the gutter-realism of today's movies. I can't help but watch old movies as a piece of living history, comparing the "then" to the "now" . I recognized the old Los Angeles neighborhood filled with 2-bedroom plaster houses that were either Tudor or Spanish - they are still there and the same homes are now worth over a million dollars; except that the streets are no longer so pristine clean. My husband, who immigrated in the late 1960s, said his first "culture shock" was how clean and orderly American cities were, and when I see this movie, I kind of begin to see what he is referring to. People today are not so attuned to one another, nor so meticulous in their grooming. It was somewhat painful to see Greek and Russian immigrants be the focus of Hollywood humor, which hasn't changed; Hollywood still aims to entertain by targeting certain types. Joan Fontaine is amazing. The smile never leaves her face, yet she subtly conveys a spectrum of emotions. She is a delight. The simple, clean optimism of this film is a pure delight. It also is a reminder of what we have lost.

And why aren't the critics giving The Promise its due praise? I am frankly tired of Hollywood do-over-and-over-and-overs.None of that in this movie. It is novel and original and will hold your interest. If it isn't nominated for awards, something really stinks in Hollywood.

The only actor I recognized was Christian Bale... and perhaps that's what made this movie so completely excellent -- the film was not ruined by miscast pop culture personalities who's only purpose is to generate box office! The casting was just perfect and the acting was completely believable. If you love details: the costumes, interiors, and other small set accessories were spot on; and the scenery was magnificent. This has all the elements we crave in a well developed movie: good script, depth in characters, suspense and excitement, exotic locals, historical accuracy and significance; a little romance, a little gore -- it was simply perfect in every way.

Like a wonderful David Lean picture, the film will sweep you up and keep you engaged. I recommend this movie as much for the production values as for the historical relevance. See it. Think about it. It will not leave you for a long time.

Bravo!!!

P.S. bring Kleenex