Worse than I remembered In my initial review of this movie, I was quite generous with some of my criticism of it, and since my brother and I watched it again yesterday through the 40th Anniversary Blu-Ray, I want to elaborate more on why I believe this movie is overrated.
The story is full of conveniences and is overall just strange for a Disney movie, and not the surreal strange like Dumbo or Pinocchio. It feels very much like Disney was really improvising the plot as they went through and didn't take time to explain things like why Toby is suddenly with the rabbit children when Skippy shoots his first arrow, how Allan-a-Dale connects to the rest of the Merry Men, how the vixen Maid Marian is related by blood to lions Prince John and King Richard, et cetera. In fact, you can actually sum up Robin Hood's plot as "That Happens: The Movie". The Phony King of England comes right out of nowhere after Love (strange it got an Academy Award nomination, because it's not really special other than to give Maid Marian another voice). Its pacing is inconsistent, and despite being set around 1194 (King Richard returned to England that year), it features badminton, balloons, and references to football (complete with the background music for the beautiful brawl being a rendition of On Wisconsin). Not to mention, despite being set in Central England, many of the characters give a feel that it would be set in the American South. The music has more of a country than medieval European feel to it, plus Trigger's crossbows are used to make rifle references. There was even one point where "Devonshire" was mispronounced (as "Devon shai-ur" rather than "Devon-shur" in proper English). Lastly, it has probably the most anti-climactic ending in any Disney movie I can remember. We had established that Robin Hood was a trickster, so of course it wouldn't be unexpected that he would feign his own death. Then we run into the cliché of "evil master gets p*ssed at his henchman", and then we cut immediately to Robin and Marian's wedding without developing King Richard or Marian any more.
Because of the anachronisms and the fact they are convinced they are telling the REAL story of Robin Hood, I am personally convinced Disney instead gave us the depiction of a group of 1973 furries who decided to parody the story of Robin Hood. I could at least respect it more that way, but until Disney confirms such (not that they would), the plot is definitely an indicator that since Walt's passing 7 years before the company had lost their way.
Another big indication that Disney was pulling no punches with being cheap is the animation. Conceptually, Don Bluth managed to bring out a great looking Robin Hood and Skippy, and some other characters do present a bit of creativity with their species (like Lady Kluck). On the other hand you have discount Baloo as Little John (both voiced by Phil Harris and having multicolored flashing eyes in their respective movies' menagerie musical numbers), discount Kaa as Sir Hiss (with identical hypnosis and contortion to match), and mice from The Aristocats. Speaking of which, Robin Hood stole a lot of its animation from earlier movies; for The Phony King of England; Maid Marian's shaking is copied from Duchess' in The Aristocats, and her clapping is Snow White's. Little John's dance with Lady Kluck in the same number is taken from Baloo's dance with King Louie in The Jungle Book. The drumming rabbit is copied from The Aristocats' "Everybody Wants to Be a Cat". Finally, during the "beautiful brawl", there is a maze lanes portion that rips off Alice in Wonderland. Of course, it does use plenty of its own animation later on, most notably for the Sheriff. The lighting messes up at times by making some characters' bodies look the same color (i.e. in the start of "Love", Robin's body starts out completely orange before his neck corrects itself to white). I don't know if I can blame Disney back in 1973 because they were becoming as poor as the Nottinghamians when John raised the taxes, but I was just resentful at how many corners they decided to cut here (they even used a live-action bell for Friar Tuck's church; it was added post-production). As the Sheriff would put it, "There's somethin' funny goin' on around here."
There is (as I had mentioned in my previous review) an alternate ending that, if they actually used, almost salvages this movie. It trades the lack of climax for a more manageable deus ex machina appearance by King Richard, and the way its heavy heart was written in (at least as shown in Most Wanted and 40th Anniversary) actually contrasts pretty nicely with the tone of the rest of the film. With a bit more polish on its script, it would have at least had the movie finish on a more satisfying note.
There are things that I will say this film does right; while the music doesn't always feel in place it's not really horrible, and it does distract a little bit from the two-bit animation it often comes with. The settings do feel appropriate for 1194 Central England, the voice acting is spot on in spite of not enough British voices, and there are occasional and intentional chuckle inducers. It still has Disney color and charm that helps it contribute somewhat to the magic, and because of this, I will say that most children will have a blast with this film. They can appreciate having a relatable character in Skippy, the fair idol of Robin Hood, the beauty of Maid Marian, and a pretty fun villain duo of Prince John and Sir Hiss. The relationship between Robin and Marian, as well as some of the writing, could potentially captivate some adults to like this movie too, if my account icon says anything about that...
So overall, is Robin Hood a bad animated movie in general? No. Is it a bad Disney movie? Yes. The sad thing is, Disney probably couldn't foresee that merely 13 years later, they were on the verge of closing Walt Disney Animation Studios for good. While The Black Cauldron would prove be their near-poison, in an alternate universe where they did fold this would not be a good film to have near the end of their résumé. It's good to watch with the kids, but don't feel overly surprised if you feel underwhelmed after watching it.