An Average Horror Film People nowadays expect too much from films, especially when it comes to horror films. When you mention the word "horror" film, what's the first thing that probably pops into your mind? Probably some scary images full of blood and gore and frightening music. In other words, we expect some scary, concrete(physical) things to look at. But people are forgetting that that's not what horror is all about. There's also emotional and psychological horror, which is just as scary. And that is what "When a Stranger Calls" is based on, and that is what the audience must realize. Now, from my personal experience, this movie didn't scare me much. So was it good? It was an "allright" film; it wasn't perfect: meaning the plot can be predictable, and the whole idea of the film was simple (A girl keeps getting some mysterious phone-calls from a guy with bad intentions.)
So how scary was the film? It honestly depends on the person watching the movie. If you watch the film with a clear and relaxed mind and try to interact with the movie by listening to the spooky background music and give the movie a chance, you will be entertained and get that creepy, spooky, and frightening feeling. After all, the movie is all psychological and it depends on the audience's imagination to scare themselves out. I also must say that the director made an excellent choice of choosing Camilla Belle, for carrying out the film, and who did an excellent performance.
In a word, "When a Stranger Calls" was an average horror film that could have done much better. Nevertheless, it will entertain you if you give the movie the chance and realize that the horror is all in the mind and imagination.