Explanations for Everything (+ thoughts) I went back to this a year after I stopped watching when it first debuted. I love all of Mike Flanagan's work, the acting is always phenomenal. It's not his best, but it may be worth it for you.
If you haven't caught Flanagan's blog post about what Season 2 was supposed to look like-or the article about it-spoilers are below (more like explanations). BUT. A few thoughts first:
1. I'm seeing a lot of "who is this for?" on streaming platforms with movies and series trying to somehow appeal to both YA and Adults, so it dips into each, and just creates confusion, frustration, boredom and likely manages to traumatize some teens.
2. Midnight Mass was 7 episodes. Man do I wish this were the same. So much repetition: Stories about not being able to change your fate, stories about what happens after, stories about what's going on between characters.
3. It felt like with these 'midnight' stories, he was trying things out. What if Mike Flanagan did a sci fi story? What if he did a detective story? Le Sigh.
3. Did anyone feel like they were literally watching his film Dr. Sleep/the Shining? The old music, the scary old lady in the bathroom, the long hallways, the redheaded woman in the woods who's very earthy but secretly has an agenda thats not great (this was so on the nose I couldn't believe it)....and on and on and on. If you need confirmation of this, the episode end that keeps zooming in on the photo of Julia James is a direct duplicate of the ending to the Shining. To be fair, if YA's haven't seen the movie, they won't catch it.
4. None of these kids look sick, they're bouncing around, leaving the hospice....did anyone in production know what a hospice was? It's pretty fast in terms of how long you're there, too. Why not just call it a residence?
5. There are so many repetitive stories and sentiments that you wonder if he was contractually obligated, and had to fill a bunch of stuff in. It's not always the director/writers fault-studio execs will flub stuff up.
6 . When you reach the halfway mark, you really have to decide if you're going to stay with him for an entire other half.
7. Again, not sure if he thinks he's catching anyone in confusion, but I always knew when it wasn't real and when it was a dream, or a fantasy, even when he wants you to think it's real, for ex, with a cold open.
8. The male janitor and the doctor-the only other adults there, it seems-really stuck out to me as being important characters, like in the Shining, almost like Smitty. I did notice that the janitor was only seen there after someone died.
9. Oh gosh, the sick kid porn. Please. Can we leave this behind with the handful we had thrown at us a decade ago? 10 years is not enough distance, and yet, we get it for 10 episodes, pretty much.
OK, here's where explanations and spoilers start!
1. Julia-do you really not think this identical woman living off the land like a gyspy is Julia Jayne? Who wouldn't know off the bat? Is it meant to be that obvious to us, but not to her? Thats just frustrating.
2. As soon as I realized only Ilonka and Kevin could see the 'Cataract Woman' and 'Mirror Man' , I realized they'd both been there before. There was the confusion about 'he and she' that also shows its hand. The visions of the old hallway, the old music....again, with so many Shining tip-offs, this is inevitable. But why are they scary looking!?
SO. Turns out, they are the reincarnated souls of the people who built the hotel which was turned into a hospice. His soul is in her, her soul is in his, and they meet each other as soul mates and know they'll find each other. Why that means the visions are terrifying, I'll never know. Here's what I did know: Flannel nightgown, you guys. Kevin wore it, the Cataract woman wore it-its easy to put together, and I was also glad it was validated with more context. The backstory they were going to share in season 2 would have explained the heartbreaking reasons why she's wondering around and saying she's hungry, why she's in the basement, why her eyes are how they are: she got dementia in her older age, and would forget to feed herself, refuse to leave the basement, etc.
3. What the heck happened with the Julia storyline? I felt like she was just cut out, but, the explanation is actually there-she wasn't really cured when she was younger, just misdiagnosed (convenient) and got sick again, so she needed to go back to perform the ritual, which, if you observed the bloody thumbprints on her own forehead instead of Ilonka's, is a giveaway-however, whether or not Julia did intend to also heal Ilonka is unclear, and I'm fine with that. I love her diabolical deranged smile as she goes up in the elevator. And in a way, we know what happens-the ritual won't work or her this time.
4. The shadow actually isn't a bad thing-apparently it's there to reassure you that you'll be ok...because it's you? Okey dokey. I'll take 'comfort in death.' It showed Anya what her life would have been, and it was depressing. I knew it wasnt real because if you had a zest for life and survived, it would either be the existence of a lifetime, or just as depressing. The shadow showed her this and so she felt ready to go.
5. Dr. Stanton is the daughter of the crazyyyy cult lady-the original-and helped everyone escape. She is a good guy. The tatoo shows she was there, and the bald head is the irony of her going through chemo for cancer as well. AND-looks like she was supposed to beat it and live, creating complicated feelings around what she does for work.
6. Yep, the janitor is the angel of death, only there when people die. Not sure what's up with the orderly/nurse, but, I did wonder if there was a time loop situation going on where the Janitor was an older version of him. The hourglass symbol offers a lot in the way of possibility.
My only lingering questions: in her Healer story, why would Ilonka's mom have saved a strange girl's life if she knew it meant abandoning her daughter!? What! We didn't know enough about this for it to make sense, only to later set up a scene where she saved Anya. But still. Why?
I assumed this was self contained, as all his other series were-I think we all got that same sinking feeling when we realized there were only 15 minutes left on episode 10: we weren't going to get any answers.
Which means, as always, please stop leaving things for an assumed Season 2, or a sequel, that never happens. Do your strongest work in a contained series or movie, which I've loved each and every one of, but cutting a few totally uneccessary episodes and replacing them with an episode that can deal with allllll of the above would have been the way to go.
I kept with it as a compelling binge watch, but was slowly dragged through a ride that had some great moments, but abruptly stopped before the best part-but because there is so much else offered here-here but not here? ;) - it's not a waste.