The man is dead, let it be! The first time I watched this movie I was truly upset. When I watch a movie billed to be a love story I expect to see a love story. This was'nt a love story. I waited and waited and waited some more to see some sparks fly and they don't. Now we get to her party and they have their dance. Now all is well ; but, no, he's gone again. "what's the deal?" On top of that, he's dead. "How can that be?" I watched it again. Now I enjoyed it because I love Sandy and more or less did'nt care about all the holes in it. 1. The fact that Alex lived in the lake house before kate. 2. The paw prints were made from the mystery dog. 3. There is no attic in the lake house and on and on to one hole after another. Forget the holes. Watch it, enjoy Sandy, great sound tract, great scenery, some good laughs, strong acting and some how or other put the guy into the ground. See it twice. Much better the second time.