Underrated, an amazing film Sidney Lumet is a director who never ceases to amaze me. He makes movies that seem to have so much thought and attention to detail, but he gets little attention, when compared to his contemporaries from NYC.
This is a movie I didn't expect to love, but it's prescient. I didn't read the book, but the script/adaptation is evocative and gives every character something smart, that their character would actually say.
The plot is basically a heist film with a subplot of a surveillance state, in which every government agency seems to be aware of the heist at every turn, without the characters having any idea. The fact that the main character, played by the inimitable Sean Connery, is released from prison after a 10 year sentence and is then trailed and surveyed at every turn is something I'm sure does not shock those of us who grew up with cell phones in our hands, but it still seems to cross several lines, he did his time.
Next, through multiple tracking shots, with perfect sound editing, Lumet tried to warn us that no matter what we do, we are being watched. The twist here is that even though we are being watched, the watchers are unable to capitalize on the information they've accumulated because it is not legal to survey someone without their knowledge. So how have the watchers adapted? They watch us through the products we are sold; through ads nowadays, through creating paranoia that requires action in the film.
A note: The scene that most stands out in my memory is when Duke comes home to make love to his girl, the camera shows us that they are being recorded through the telephone line. I got chills there.
An Actor's note: Martin Balsam is amazing, and hilarious, in a tremendous side role. He plays a gay man respectably, especially for 1971.
in conclusion, Lumet is one of America's GOATs, and this is my 3rd favorite from him, behind only Network and Dog Day Afternoon, which are other American neo realism films that everyone must see.
The Anderson Files is crisp, meticulous, intelligent, and fun. The characters are great and the score is fire. Lastly, this is Walken's first movie role. He steals every second of screen time that he is given.
9/10, underrated beyond belief.