The Baywatch rumor originated from Season 2, Episode 2 of The Valley. Jesse Lally spoke to Scheana Shay about his new girlfriend, Lacy Nicole. There was a rumor that she cheated on him with multiple men, including “the guy from Baywatch.” Nicole Eggert, who starred on the original series, shared her thoughts on this mystery.

Who’s The Guy From Baywatch?

Jesse met with his ex-wife, Michelle. The two had a tense discussion about co-parenting. Somehow, the conversation shifted to Michelle accusing Jesse’s new girlfriend of talking about him behind his back. She then revealed a claim that Lacy told Scheana that she had cheated on Jesse more than once.

Jesse immediately called up Scheana on the phone, who confirmed the rumor. She wouldn’t name who “the guy from Baywatch is.” However, this had fans wondering who the guy could be. Social media immediately burned up with questions like, “Who is the guy from Baywatch?...