“Elden Ring fans when they play an actual Souls game”: The Soulsborne Gatekeeping Continues as Shadow of the Erdtree Players Revisit (and Fail At) Dark Souls

The gaming community is once again debating the difficulty and mechanics of FromSoftware’s popular titles. This time, it’s Elden Ring and its expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, versus the classic Dark Souls 1.
The comparison has sparked a lot of conversation among fans, with many concluding that the first Dark Souls game, despite its legendary status, feels a lot clunkier in comparison.
The Clunky Controls of Dark Souls 1
Elden Ring is definitely a lot smoother than Dark Souls 1. Image via FromSoftware.
One tweet that’s been making the rounds states that going from Elden Ring to Dark Souls is rather painful, clunky, and tedious. This pretty much sums up the feelings of many newer fans who are diving into the older games for the first time. They find that the first Souls game, while still a fantastic game, has some rough edges when it comes to controls and gameplay,...
The comparison has sparked a lot of conversation among fans, with many concluding that the first Dark Souls game, despite its legendary status, feels a lot clunkier in comparison.
The Clunky Controls of Dark Souls 1
Elden Ring is definitely a lot smoother than Dark Souls 1. Image via FromSoftware.
One tweet that’s been making the rounds states that going from Elden Ring to Dark Souls is rather painful, clunky, and tedious. This pretty much sums up the feelings of many newer fans who are diving into the older games for the first time. They find that the first Souls game, while still a fantastic game, has some rough edges when it comes to controls and gameplay,...
- 7/1/2024
- by Suhaib Adeel
- FandomWire
Similar News
Hugh Laurie To Play Crime Syndicate Head In New Thriller Series Alongside Game Of Thrones & Westworld Stars
- 5/7/2025
- by Adam Bentz
- ScreenRant

Hugh Laurie to Topline Thriller ‘The Wanted Man’ at Apple TV+
- 5/7/2025
- by Rick Porter
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News

Hugh Laurie to Lead Apple TV+ Thriller ‘The Wanted Man’ Alongside Thandiwe Newton and Fionn Whitehead
- 5/7/2025
- by Ellise Shafer
- Variety Film + TV

Without Vince McMahon’s Cruel Prank on Mark Henry, WWE Hall of Pain Storyline Might Not Have Happened
- 5/7/2025
- by Arko Bhattacharyya
- FandomWire
Agents of Shield’s Clark Gregg Followed One Golden Rule When He Guest-Starred in The West Wing
- 5/7/2025
- by Visarg Acharya
- FandomWire

How Many Episodes of ‘Andor’ Season 2 Are Remaining? Episode 10 Release Date and What to Expect
- 5/7/2025
- by Sonika Kamble
- FandomWire

Hidetaka Miyazaki Fans Are Already Trolling Elden Ring Movie Leaks
- 5/7/2025
- by Amlan Roy
- FandomWire

Elden Ring: Alex Garland to direct video game adaptation for A24?
- 5/7/2025
- by Cody Hamman
- JoBlo.com

Game of Thrones star Sophie Turner marvels at the return of dire wolves
- 5/7/2025
- by Dan Selcke
- Winter Is Coming

IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.