Barry Levinson is not a name one would usually associate with the horror genre. The Academy Award-winning director — best known for "Rain Man," "Wag the Dog," and "Diner" — has mostly leaned toward satirical comedies or tense drama-thrillers throughout his career. While prepping for a documentary about the pollution plaguing the Chesapeake Bay in 2012, Levinson decided to forego the project in favor of a found-footage eco-horror that would mix fact with fiction to disturbing effect. This endeavor was "The Bay," a mockumentary-style exploration of a contagion premise that feels almost prescient within the context of our post-pandemic world. Despite being the director's sole foray into horror, Levinson re-invigorates the found-footage subgenre by injecting it with one of the most primal fears accompanying a pandemic: the callous cruelty of wilful inaction.

It is worth noting that Levinson incorporated the scientific research for the abandoned Chesapeake documentary into the film's narrative framework, and...