After two decades, American Idol is bringing back one of its most iconic winners, Carrie Underwood—but not in the way fans might have expected.

The country music star is set to return, not as a performer, but as a judge on the very show that launched her career. While this full-circle moment has thrilled fans, it’s not the only thing they’re talking about.

A Homecoming That Has American Idol Fans Buzzing

Every new season of American Idol stirs excitement, but this time, there’s a special reason why audiences are eagerly awaiting its return. Carrie Underwood, who won the competition 20 years ago, will be stepping into a different role—joining the judges’ panel.

For longtime viewers, seeing her go from contestant to industry icon to mentor is a nostalgic moment that highlights just how far she has come.

In anticipation of the new season, American Idol’s...