We’ve seen men struggle with their final decision on The Bachelor before — it’s practically a season finale staple at this point — but we’ve never seen a Bachelor stay undecided as looooong as Grant did in Monday’s agonizing finale. (Sure, Brad Womack infamously picked neither of his final two women in his first Bachelor stint… but at least he made a decision to pick no one!)

So who did Grant ultimately choose between Litia and Juliana? (And how great will his final choice feel when she sees how late in the game he decided?) Monday’s three-hour...