Sutton Foster has always been Broadway’s shining star. But lately, it’s not just her stage magic making headlines—there’s been some behind-the-scenes buzz too, and it has everything to do with her rumored closeness to Hugh Jackman.

Ever since the duo teamed up for The Music Man, fans have been picking up on a little something extra between them. That sparkling chemistry didn’t just stay on stage—it seemed to follow them off it, and well, you know how fast the rumor mill spins when sparks are flying.

But before Jackman’s name started floating around in the gossip circles, Foster was happily married to screenwriter Ted Griffin. They were together for nearly a decade, and from the outside, it seemed perfect.

So when news of their split broke, around the same time Foster and Jackman were spending more time together, it caught a lot of people off guard.