La vieille dame indigne (1965) User Reviews (5)

Sylvie, star at last!

[dbdumonteil · 9/10 · 14 February 2006]

It was to be Sylvie's last part and ,although she made a brilliant career ,it was the only movie where she got the lead.It would be an insult to the users' culture to mention all the great French works she was in.Just check her filmography,they are all in here:Carné,Duvivier,Clouzot,Bresson,Autant-Lara,Grémillon,and even (yuk) Vadim.

"The shameless old lady" was a (very) short story by Bertold Brecht ("Die unwürdige Greisin" ) from a book called "Kalender Gechichten" .The scenarists were faithful to the German writer's spirit and they developed the plot with taste .

A sixty-something woman became a widow .All her life,she had been cooking ,washing and taking care of her family.A woman's work is never done.So she decided she would live for herself: she would go to the pictures ,she would buy a car and that's exactly what she did.

Bertold Brecht told us so:she had two lives:the first one was a long busy one,the second one was very short;but she ate the bread of life till its last crumbs (that's the last line of his story) The first part of her life is summarized during the cast and credits when old black and white photographs appear on the screen while we can hear Jean Ferrat's beautiful song "On ne Voit Pas le Temps Passer" (=time passes you by).The second one is the film itself and it's full of joie de vivre,it's really a film about happiness,as "Babette's feast" would be twenty years later.

A must.

For keeps

[TigressLils · 10/10 · 21 May 2009]

This is a film I saw in 1968, being a young adult and have never forgotten. It's a shame it is not possible to find it on DVD anywhere, and I have checked shops in France, England and the USA. I'd love to have it for keeps. Possibly it is not or would not be everybody's cup of tea but it is a lesson of life with a wonderful performance by the great Sylvie. There are many European films, be them French, Spanish, Italian, German, et al, that are great works of art and of thought that are not marketed even in their own countries. One wonders why. Let's hope one day it will easier to find them, to enjoy them again and to be able to teach their quality to younger people.

Wonderful, wise, sly comedy/drama about life, aging and being oneself

[runamokprods · 9/10 · 14 July 2010]

Sweet, simple, moving, funny, well acted French film of old woman 'finding' herself after her husband's death, and the struggle her family has in accepting and dealing with the new her.

Quietly subversive, it's based on a story by Brecht.

While we're set up to expect a tragic tale of an old woman widowed and alone, instead we're treated to a wonderfully life affirming saga of how it's never too late to change, to grow, and to become young in spirit.

Great theme song, too.

The saddest thing is that such a wonderful (and well loved) film is so hard to find. This best I've been able to do is a truly bad quality VHS tape from some years back. This minor classic is worthy of far better.

very good ensemble acting, touching cross generational film

[petertor · 9/10 · 26 July 2003]

I saw this film in Paris in its original release at 20 years of age, and it has always stayed with me. If the film has a message, it might be to live life with dignity, in spite of the weaknesses of others and your own burdens, and when the chance presents itself to live it to its fullest. The movie's ending, when we see the photos of Sylvie "en vacances", is as poignant as I have experienced.

Now if I can only find out where to rent it, to enjoy it again.

"She Goes to the Cinema!! I Don't Go to the Cinema!""

[HarlowMGM · 10/10 · 13 June 2022]

I have wanted to see this film for around forty years, since I first read the brief reviews in the Leonard Maltin and Steven Scheuer film guides. And at last I have - and it was worth the wait!! Veteran French character actress Sylvie (whose film career started in the 1910's) stars as Berthe, an elderly woman in her eighties whose husband of sixty years has just died. The duo had lived quietly and apparently not that happily. A rather frosty family whose grown children are distant emotionally if not location-wise and rarely visit. The film follows Sylvie's months following her husband's death as she ventures out from the small apartment and local neighborhood and starts walking around the big city to discover the modern world, making friends with a thirtyish woman of dubious virtue and a eccentric fortyish man who runs a shoe repair shop. The local villagers are scandalized by the old gal venturing out into world, particularly with such questionable associates and Berthe's neurotic, luckless, failed businessman son Albert (Etienne Bherry) is especially concerned, sending his 20ish son Pierre (Victor Lanoux), an aimless young man who plays pop music with his buddies, to check on the old gal.

If you are expecting a Gallic version of a Ruth Gordon vehicle, this is not it. This is a gentle, slice of life drama (some have labeled it a comedy but there is only a mild touch of humor in it) with a moving performance by Sylvie that is so natural it evokes the legend of Laurette Taylor in "The Glass Menagerie". Sylvie and the film both won many deserved honors at film Festivals for this beautiful film but the supporting cast is equally good, especially Lanoux, Berry, and Malka Ribowska as the easy living and easy loving waitress Rosalie. I wasn't familiar with any of these French actors before, sadly this trio all passed away within the last five years or so (2022). The ending is one of the most tastefully poignant film climaxes I have ever seen. A true masterpiece, it sadly is rarely mentioned in film histories of French cinema but deserves to be noted in depth.