Tomas de Torquemada
King Ferdinand
Christopher Columbus (as George Corraface)
Queen Isabella of Castille
Martin Pinzon
Beatriz (as Catherine Zeta Jones)
Harana
Alvaro Harana (as Benicio del Toro)
King John (as Mathieu Carriere)
Vicente Pinzon
De La Cosa
Fra Perez
Roldan
Benjamin
Terreros
De Torres
Gonzalo
Morales (as Chris Hunter)
Bives
Escobedo
Inquisitor's Spy
Lord Guarco
Isaac
Joseph
Monsignor Camos
Chios Mapmaker
Alcalde of Malaga
1st Alguazil
Indian Chieftain
Indian Girl (as Tailinh Forest Flower)
Indian Brave
Indian Guide
Chios Vendor
Harana's Wife
Prison Officer
Healthy Prisoner
First Mate of Pinta
Diego Age 8
Diego Age 11
Fernando
Rodrigo de Triana
Sailor in Tavern
Prostitute (uncredited)
Nobleman (uncredited)
Extra (uncredited)