Really like to love a good deal of Popeye cartoons and like the character of Popeye. Will admit though to preferring the Popeye cartoons from the Dave Fleischer era, the cartoons tend to be funnier and there is more originality and more risk taking in some of them. 'Hill-Billing and Cooing' is a late Popeye cartoon and made in Famous Studios' roughest and most variable period where budgets were much smaller in particularly the animation and deadlines and time constraints were shorter and tighter.
One would not think that watching 'Hill-Billing and Cooing'. The title is not the appetising of ones, but the cartoon itself is great. 'Hill-Billing and Cooing' is a strong contender for the best Popeye cartoon of the late 50s, one of the few great ones of that decade and is one of the few late 50s Famous Studios (one of the studio's weaker periods) cartoons overall to be above very good. There are many reasons to love it, but that it is quite a unique Popeye cartoon is a primary reason.
The only thing that wasn't so good was at times some of the animation. The budget and time constraints at times show in some rushed looking drawing and a lack of finnese.
Did think though that most of the animation for this period was not bad at all, with vibrant colour and beautiful attention to detail. The best thing about 'Hill-Billing and Cooing' is the music score. It's beautifully orchestrated, rhythmically it's full of energy and there is so much character, it's also brilliant in not just adding to the action but enhancing it.
'Hill-Billing and Cooing' is full of gags and all are very amusing to hilarious. Popeye is amusing and easy to root for and Possum Pearl is a unique and quite riotous supporting character. The biggest surprise is Olive at her most interesting, she is a character that tends to be underused and not always that interesting in personality but here she is a lot of fun and it was great to see a role reversal that saw her in the role that Popeye usually fills. That's the biggest interest point of the cartoon and what makes it stand out.
Liked the story too, which is full of energy and is eventful and different. Not a predictable cartoon this time thanks to the role reversal and difference in character dynamic as a result of that. Jack Mercer and Mae Questel do great jobs providing the voice work, of the voice actors to voice Popeye and Olive they for me were the ones that make the most impression on me. Judy Canova was clearly having fun as well.
Overall, great. 9/10.