Dr. Sam Sheppard
Sam Reese Sheppard (segment "Chip")
Marilyn Sheppard
Richard Eberling (in jail)
Dr. Robert Sheppard
Sam Reese - Age 7 / Age 10
Sam Reese - Age 17
Ariane - Age 25 / Age 64
Terry Gilbert
Cayahoga County Coroner
Prosecutor Mahon
Alisa
R.A. Sheppard
Corrigan
Ethel Sheppard
Susan Hayes
Samuel Gerber
Spen Houk
Judge Blythin
Judge Suster
Older Lund
Boston Bruiser
Motel Woman
Russ Siler
Bus Kid #1
Bus Kid #2
Court Reporter
Anesthesiologist
Young Lund
Jury Foreman (as Dom Fiore)
Young Eberling (as Mark Cameron Fraser)
Former Guard
Lou Romano
Pretty Nurse
Conservative Debater
Prison Guard
Patient's Mother
Les Hoversten
College Kid (as Balazs Koos)
Administrator (as Michael Kramer)
Esther Houk (as Trulie Macleod)
O.R. Nurse (as Nancy Mcalear)
Eleanor Blanchard (as Pat Moffatt)
Flight Attendant
Mrs. Gilbert
Mrs. Avery
Candy Romano
Funeral Reporter
Officer Exner
Pastor Demski