Add a Review

  • After having read the book by Michelle Magorian, which is engaging and of interest, as all of her books are, this make was very disappointing. Nothing seemed to fit well in terms of the plot, it was unfocused, and major storylines had been left out as the book progressed. There was very good acting, especially from Stephanie Cole, Sarah Lancashire, and newcomer Jessica Fox, but it is by no means up to scratch on Goodnight Mr. Tom. That was much better directed and was a far more convincing adaptation. For all its faults however, it kept me going to the end, and was enjoyable. Wouldn't watch it again, though I would like to see the earlier version to compare.

    6 out of 10 (That's generous).
  • Warning: Spoilers
    This was a great TV movie, but it really missed the point of the book. Rusty, in the book, is not able to accept the changes in her mother that occur over the war period, just as her mother cannot accept the changes in Rusty until the end of the book. The Disney movie captured this well even if it did gloss over the more brutal aspects of her parents' relationship. This movie seemed more a vehicle for Sarah Lancaster and a fleshing out of Peggy's character than the mother and daughter relationship that is central to the book. It also really doesn't spend much time on Rusty's own difficulties fitting in to post-war Britain after being a sea-vacuee to America for five years. Jessica Fox did a marvelous job with what she was given as did the rest of the cast, and it made a good movie, but the 1996 Disney movie is truer to the heart of the novel, and it's really ashame it's out of print so most viewers will not be able to compare them.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    It's a clash of cultures and family values in this postwar drama about a young girl (Jessica Fox) returning to her family after spending time in America during World War Two. At first, she clashes with her mother (Sarah Lancashire), but must come to her support when they have to move back in with the prickly Rosemary Leach, the mother of Lancashire's husband, Adrian Lukis, who is away wrapping things up after the end of the war. The only other support they have is from the wonderful Stephanie Cole who can't do much from the house where she lived with Lancashire before they had to move. Lukis's return creates more conflict as the family realizes how much has changed, and Leach manipulates him into sending Fox back to school, a place she hates. It's going to take a lot of strength to get through these trying times, and the independence that Lancashire has gained being on her own will certainly come into play.

    The miserable old sow that Leach plays is a manipulative old bag that pushes everybody around and manipulates the situation to her advantage, obviously just liking her daughter-in-law and wanting to see the marriage come to an end. She's a stark contrast to the wonderful character played by Cole, reminding me a lot of Dame Margaret Rutherford. This is the antithesis of "The Best Years of Our Lives" where changes in women after the war were working out and most couples had a happy ending. Fox is terrific as the young Rosemary, feisty and determined, not one to be kept quiet as her grandmother demands. The brother played by Skye King is a bit challenged to put it gently. There's a subplot concerning a war Widow who remarries only to find out that her husband is still living. This is a nice drama about losing any kind of consequences of the end of war that hits normal homes very personally, well-acted and well written.
  • I wasn't sure I was going to enjoy this movie because it seemed to move at a snail's pace. It turns out this approach was perfect. Without realizing it until half way through the movie, I discovered that I had established an emotional relationship with each character, a development I wasn't expecting. Well done. Absolutely worth watching. And, once again, Sarah Lancashire was outstanding. That slow burn hit all the right notes.