Self - Narrator (voice)
Butch
Ronnie
Reenactment
Dawn
George
Self (archive footage) (as Ronald DeFeo Jr.)
Self - Journalist
Self - Psychic
Self - Parapsychologist (as Prof Dr Hans Holzer)
Self - Next Door Neighbour
Self - Parapsychologist
Self - Paranormal Investigator (as Roxanne Kaplan)
Self
Self (archive footage) (as Kathleen Lutz)
Self - Journalist & Broadcaster
Self - Author: 'The Night the DeFeos Died' (as Rick Osuna)
Self - Screenwriter: 'The Amityville Horror'
Self - Amityville Bar Owner
Self - DeFeo's Attorney