Blair Brown credited as playing...
Attorney Lynne Riff
- Attorney Lynne Riff: So, uh, you say Andrea and Paige never asked you to stop. Let me ask you this: did Emily?
- Brittany O'Malley: [scoffs] I guess.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: You guess? What, didn't she beg you to stop? Didn't she offer you money, her diamond earrings, anything you wanted?
- Brittany O'Malley: Yes.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: Didn't she cry out for her mother, and you thought that was funny?
- Brittany O'Malley: [defiant stare] Yes.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: Who was it that cut Emily's skin with scissors over 100 times?
- Brittany O'Malley: I did.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: And who brought a knife and later used it to cut Emily's throat?
- Brittany O'Malley: Me.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: And the cigarettes you went out to buy, you used those to burn Emily's skin, right?
- Brittany O'Malley: Right.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: So the truth is, you didn't want Andrea and Paige to help you torture and kill Emily. You just wanted an audience.
- Casey Novak: Objection.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: Withdrawn. Nothing further.
- Casey Novak: You feel bad now for everything that happened to Emily.
- Andrea Kent: Yes. When I got home that morning, I threw up. But I was afraid.
- Casey Novak: Of getting caught? Of Brittany?
- Andrea Kent: No. I was afraid if I told, Brittany wouldn't be my friend.
- Casey Novak: You said your cover story was going out to celebrate your birthday. January... that makes you a Capricorn, right?
- Andrea Kent: Yeah.
- Casey Novak: What's your birthstone?
- Roger Kressler: Objection. Relevance?
- Casey Novak: I'm getting to it, Your Honor.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: Hurry it up, Ms. Novak. The witness will answer the question.
- Andrea Kent: My birthstone's garnet.
- Casey Novak: That's what I thought. I see you're wearing your class ring. That's my birthstone: sapphire. September birthday. You know who else had a September birthday, Andrea?
- Roger Kressler: Objection.
- Attorney Lynne Riff: Relevance?
- Judge Lena Petrovsky: Overruled.
- Casey Novak: Didn't Emily have a September birthday?
- Andrea Kent: I don't know.
- Casey Novak: Emily had a class ring. It was engraved with her name. It was never found with her body. Your Honor, would you instruct the defendant to remove her ring?
- Judge Lena Petrovsky: Hand it to me, Ms. Kent.
- [pause]
- Andrea Kent: [blurts] Paige gave it to me. She took it off Emily after she was dead!
- Paige Summerbee: You're a liar! You took her Prada purse!
- Attorney Lynne Riff: [stands up] Sidebar, Your Honor.
- Andrea Kent: She's got Emily's clothes, too! The ones with all the blood on them!
- Casey Novak: [walks towards the witness stand, directly facing Andrea] If you feel so bad about what happened, then why are you wearing a dead girl's ring?