Episode list

A woman of faith, seventy-seven-year-old Susan Hernandez seems like the last person police would expect to find murdered in her basement. Searching for suspects high and far, detectives turn over every stone in the hunt for Susan's killer, with a result that shakes the town to its core.

Brucetravius Frazier is found dead in his car from a gunshot wound to his head. When an attempt is made on the life of a witness, police realize they are not dealing with the average killer and must work quickly to bring them to justice.

Samantha Guthrie's parents are desperately looking for their missing child. As the police search reveals many players in this mystery, there is one common thread - the Lillian St. house.

In Grand Rapids, local mother Laurie Lundeberg is gunned down outside her home. Detectives must wrestle with not only finding out who committed this awful crime, but also why? On top of that, making matters worse, the killer strikes again.

In Akron, Ohio local antiques dealer Mary Kay Wohlfarth has mysteriously vanished. Detectives must race to find the elderly woman, leaving no stone unturned. However, finding Mary Kay might just lead to more questions than answers.

Detectives in Waynesfield, Ohio are left with a grim mystery when they discover the lifeless body of Erin Mulcahy. The pressure is now on the police department to catch those responsible for the town's first murder in over fifty years.

Jamie Baker, leaves behind her family when she is found murdered with a bullet wound through her back. The mystery only deepens when police dig into her last moments and ultimately discover what exactly transpired the night she was killed.

When workers find a decomposed body on an abandoned property in Ohio, Paulding County Sheriff deputies are called to the scene. The findings of the homicide investigation that follows sends shockwaves throughout the Amish community.

The town of Fort Smith Arkansas is left reeling when an elderly, retired school teacher is found bludgeoned to death. When the person responsible is brought to justice, an unlikely perpetrator is revealed.

Local police are forced to confront their worst fears when the body of a local EMT is found at her home in Columbus, Georgia. The findings of the ensuing investigation shocks the wider community and tests the public's faith in law enforcement itself.

On December 16, 2016, Michael Agerter is found dead in his car in the garage of his rental home on Sagebrush Trail in Maricopa, Arizona. Police locate video surveillance cameras and build a case against Kathryn Sinkevitch, his former girlfriend and mother of his child.

The mother to five children, Samantha Wohlford arranged a murder plot to have her allegedly abusive husband Ernie Ibarra, a Titus County tattoo artist, killed. Titus County Sheriff's Office authorities rushed to the residence of Ernie and Samantha after receiving a distressed 911 call, claiming that Samantha had been tied up and gagged by intruders, and that Ernie had been pistol-whipped and abducted. The detectives did not think that the story matched the evidence at the scene, and dug deeper to get to the truth.

A retirement community in Evansville, Ind., reels when police find Odie Carrier Jr. mortally shot in his own home; puzzled even more by the surprising way he died, police must work quickly if they are going to find the person responsible.

September 2019: In Jonesboro, Arkansas, authorities investigate the death of Steven McQuay, age 56, after his badly beaten body turns up in the back of a pickup truck. When the results of the victim's toxicology report arrive, the entire investigation plunges into a tailspin. Through hard work, the detectives identify William Weston Moon as the suspect in McQuay's murder. In the end, William Moon was arrested and charged with second-degree murder. He later agreed to plead guilty and had his charge downgraded to manslaughter. He was sentenced to ten years in prison.

A late-night shooting at an apartment complex in Hot Springs, Arkansas, leaves a young man dead during a drug deal gone bad. Police question the person responsible for luring the victim to his death.

The Flagler County, Florida, Sheriff's Office investigates the shooting of an 18-year-old high school track star, Curtis Israel Gray. The case threatens to go cold before a source close to home delivers the prime suspect straight to the Sheriff's front door.

A chilling confession ultimately tells all after a relative finds Cindy Testerman, age 62, strangled to death in her own home and a second woman, Judy Slebzak, goes missing.

Officers find Tyrone Hassel III shot to death outside his father's home while on holiday leave from the Army. Investigators must unravel a real whodunit, and when the killer finally comes out, the detectives can't hide their shock.

The Bryan, Texas, Police Department investigates the shooting of 23-year-old local landscaper Jose Armando Pina. A masked perpetrator flees the area via a path thick with brambles, leaving behind vital evidence.

2019: Police find 44-year-old Orlando S. Euell's body left for dead on the side of the road in the south side of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He has been shot and pushed out of the vehicle onto the curb. Despite attempts to save his life, Euell was pronounced dead at the scene as a result of a single gunshot wound. Police examine extensive surveillance footage to learn about Orlando's last moments, including footage of him getting into the car that would take him to his death. In the end, Keaira Walker was charged in fatal shooting of Orlando Euell at 25th and Pierce Streets, which happened during a drug transaction. She was sentenced to 16 years in prison for the homicide.

Lima, Ohio police race to a chaotic scene at nightclub following a shooting that leaves one person dead and multiple others injured. They try to identify the shooter and dozens of patrons flee in fear confusing first responders.

December 2017, A Drug Deal Gone Very Bad: Police Officers with the Evansville Indiana Police Department arrived at a parking lot behind Rick's Bar to find a shooting victim, 20-year-old Brandon Waldroup barely alive and needing medical attention. The stakes get even higher in this case after the police realize there might be another injured victim, Christopher, who is now missing. Brandon was able to survive his gunshot wounds and gives the detectives vital information to help solve the case. Brandon Waldroup and Christopher Hoefling had gone to the parking lot to sell marijuana. One of the drug buyers shot at both Brandon and Christopher. Brandon was pulled out of the vehicle by the shooter but Christopher was left in the car when it was stolen by the drug buyers. Soon, the police find the stolen car parked in a garage with Christopher's body inside. In the end, habitual offender Earl Bernard Martin, aka Earl Martin of 906 Bellemeade Avenue, Evansville, Indiana is arrested and was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 135 years in jail. His accomplice and co-worker, Jalil Fellows, takes a plea deal and admits to his participation in the crime. Jalil is sentenced to 4 years in jail for robbery.

August 27, 2017, Evansville, Indiana: Anthony Blaylock, age 32, was shot and killed outside the American Legion Hall at 1127 Chestnut Street, Evansville, IN. The killer was habitual offender Darius Bushrod. Investigators were able to link Bushrod to the crime using surveillance video. In September 2018, Bushrod was convicted of Blaylock's murder and was sentenced to 75 years in prison. Blaylock's sister, Zaire O'Neal, speaks about how much she loved and admired her older brother.