Self - Narrator (voice)
Joy (segment "Nevada: Dark Lights")
Roy (segment "Nevada: Dark Lights")
Junkie (Male) (segment "Nevada: Dark Lights")
Junkie (Female) (segment "Nevada: Dark Lights")
Choir Boy (segment "Nevada: Dark Lights")
Hitchhiker (segment "North Carolina: Don't Drink the Water")
Misandrist Serial Killer (segment "North Carolina: Don't Drink the Water")
Caged Slave (segment "North Carolina: Don't Drink the Water")
Succubus (segment "Florida: The Succubus") (as Lacie James)
Lover (segment "Florida: The Succubus")
Leah (segment "California: Vexed")
Nick (segment "California: Vexed") (as Baker Chase Powell)
Dream Monster (segment "California: Vexed") (as Richard Cisneros-Jones)
Dream Monster (segment "California: Vexed")
Demonic Creature (segment "California: Vexed")
Horror Movie Victim (segment "California: Vexed") (voice)
Charlotte (segment "Connecticut: The Locket")
Mary (segment "Connecticut: The Locket") (as Lilly Spencer)
Jerimiah (segment "Connecticut: The Locket")
The Starlet / Teddy (segment "New Hampshire: Teddy #Scarebear")
The Best Director / Teddy (segment "New Hampshire: Teddy #Scarebear")
Teddy (segment "New Hampshire: Teddy #Scarebear")
(segment "New Hampshire: Teddy #Scarebear") (voice)
Kristy (segment "Utah: Billy Ungodly Hour")
Lisa (segment "Utah: Billy Ungodly Hour")
Abatu (segment "Utah: Billy Ungodly Hour")
Liam (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
The Witch (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
Emma (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
Oliver (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
Mia (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
Dustin (segment "Maine: Dirigo")
Boy (segment "Arkansas: Claw Hollow")
Ghost (segment "Arkansas: Claw Hollow")
Mama (segment "Arkansas: Claw Hollow")
Jade (segment "Michigan: Red Abyss")
Dean (segment "Michigan: Red Abyss")
Tyler (segment "Michigan: Red Abyss")
Dad (segment "Michigan: Red Abyss")
(segment "Arizona: Entropic") (voice)
(segment "Arizona: Entropic") (voice) (as Bradford Uyeda)
Martin (segment "Washington: Needlework")
The Corpse (segment "Washington: Needlework")
The Creature (segment "Washington: Needlework")
Elysia (segment "Pennsylvania: Elysia")
Molly (segment "Pennsylvania: Elysia")
Ryan (segment "Pennsylvania: Elysia")
Henry (segment "Pennsylvania: Elysia") (as Bob Heath)
Gary (segment "Missouri: Crockpot")
Tina (segment "Missouri: Crockpot")
Mom (segment "Missouri: Crockpot")
(segment "Missouri: Crockpot")
Dad (segment "Missouri: Crockpot") (voice)
Girl in Movie (segment "Missouri: Crockpot") (as Laurie Winkel)
Sophie (as Christina Gluszczak)
Buffalo Bill