User reviews

What's really going on with the writers this season, a great episode and then a bad one I want my favorite show to come back as it was.

Did anyone think we wanted a taylor kelly heavy episod !!

Suriously Its existence is absolutely useless.

I'm not going to be the person who is going to give ultimate low score only because a character I hate got focus and a "fav" is nowhere to be seen. This episode was bad, but not that awfully bad, just by focusing on secondary characters.

I'm going to be fair.

The only good scenes on this episode were the ones with the main cast (mostly in the beginning and the ending).

So basically:

• The firefighter action in the beginning
• Harry taking the first step to move on from his trauma
• Harry and Lou bonding
• Notice how the latest 2 points are me stretching a single scene from the ending in part
• Lou (I actually want to se more of him)
• Grant-Nash family finally reunited after the Jeffrey trauma
• Chimney surprise appearance
• Karen and Hen (although I don't particularly like how they recycled the Eva story line again, it felt a bit out of nowhere)

With the positive point said, my general thoughts about this episode are all about how the staff behind this show obviously need to work out the communication between their departments (Marketing mostly) because nothing from the promo was on the ep, heck barely the main characters were on it, LOL, They got as ghosted as the ghost roommate call.

Now let me be honest, I don't mind other secondary characters such as David (in next ep) Lou or (even) Taylor getting the a spotlight, if it is for the plot to move on and make the show better. The thing is: this ep didn't feel like that. We got a single call, then the focus shifted to secondary characters who kept going in circles for 40 minutes until suddenly the episode had to be over.

Now, I can see Lou bonding with Harry as a positive thing for the plot since it helped Harry to move on from his trauma in some extent, but this wasn't in Lou story-line focus, it was Harry's. Now I can only hope this Taylor story line is the writers giving a last screen-time to build up the character leaving, because there is not much explanation on why they did a morning news journalist reporter play detective.

My excitement didn't last for long. Where are the ghost stories? This episode was bizzare. It seems production lost their ability to make actual horror stuff like they did, in the older seasons.

One of the best episodes of this season!!! Loving all the backstory some of the side characters are getting, can't wait for them to explore them more deeply.

Absolutely loved this episode, one of the best they've ever made! Cannot wait for certain storylines to continue in future episodes especially certain relationships. The set up for certain character developments got me really excited for the rest of the season.

Ok....what was that?? Not sure where to even start with this episode. Clearly the writers didn't either? How was half the promo cut from the episode? It looked like they'd sprinke some fun in there (the ghost roomate? Ravi teasing buck?), which was needed more than ever this season but somehow that got cut for miss wannabe Nancy Drew's storyline? That is certainly...a choice? Didn't feel like a Halloween episode at all, guess that's why it got switched.

Was nice to see Chim again....and Eli....but kinda disappointed he still seems to be hating on Buck 😬. I really wish this brought them closer together and not further apart. Sigh.

Really felt for Karen and always love the Karen and Hen storyline but man....can we please leave Eva behind?? And little Harry was a star but please can we finally be done with Jeffrey? (will also note May was great).

But all these storylines mixed in with whatever they are trying to get at with Taylor Kelly was so confusing and muddled. I want to see the core casts issues resolved, I really can't see who cares enough about TKelly to have her storyline be the focus of a whole episode. Also Buck, lol, you're irritation shines through more than ever. Detective Ransome was speaking for all of us too.

And I get it was a jam packed episode, but damn, not even a mention of Eddie? After what he went through last ep? Couldn't even have him send a photo of him trick or treating with Chris or literally anything? 911 if you don't deal with the aftermath of last ep and it's parallel to 3x13-14.... I don't even know what to say anymore 😭

You know this may have been the worst ep of the season (and I thought peer pressure took the cake there), it's constantly up and down week to week. The consistency in episodes it's jarring and seems thrown together last minute at best. They really need to come through for mid season finale.....

See what happens when you don't show Eddie Diaz in an episode?

I'm sorry but this was just a mess.

Taylor isn't an important enough character to have a whole storyline in an episode so I'm HOPING this was just a set up to her leaving the show. Hope she confronts Buck about her past (the article) and she leaves to become an investigator or whatever, I don't care. Either way, their relationship definitely isn't working and neither are her storylines.

My highlights were Chimney (I have missed him SO much. The sooner Maddie comes back the better for everyone - and the show) and Karen. The rest was just MEH. Also glad this Harry storyline is finally over.

Not even gonna talk about the fact that this was supposed to be a fun lighthearted episode according to the promo and we got the opposite. This season is just so HEAVY, I was really looking forward to scenes like Ravi scaring Buck, them talking about ghosts or whatever. That whole part was completely cut out of the episode and for what? Taylor Kelly playing detective? No thanks.

I just hope that things can go back to normal after the midseason finale. I miss the old 911.

I just watched this and can't remember a thing it was supposed to be a Halloween episode but it was just about characters that aren't even central to the plot truly the worst episode of 911 In 5 years Chim and Karen couldn't even save It Taylor and the detective stuff was so so boring she's so unlikeable but in the most uninteresting way possible Eddie was absent and the other mains were barely apart of it a bland dumpster fire....

That was the worst episode I've ever seen. Thanks to Karen and Chim for making this better because that was THE MOST BORING EPISODE EVER. Anyways, nobody wants to see such a boring character like Taylor Kelly having a backstory when they can't even focus in the main characters. What about Eddie's trauma, what happened with his panic attacks? I hope they fix this soon, because I'm not watching the next episode.

Really no eddie, no calls, no firefighters practically?!!!and we have to put up with tkelly most of the episode, this sucks. They no longer make want to see the show.

THIS SEASON HAS BEEN QUITE A DISAPPOINTMENT. STORIES ARE BASIC. THEY ARE NOT EVEN TAKING CARE OF THEIR MAIN CHARACTERS AND THEIR MENTAL HEALTH. NEW CHARACTERS ARE UNNECESSARY. TAYLOR KELLY MUST GO. SHE IS SO ANNOYING. THIS WHOLE HARRY SITUATION IS BORING. IF THEY DONT CARE ABOUT THE MAIN CHARACTERS' MENTAL HEALTH WE WE WOULD BE INTERESTED IN HIS. SO DONE WITH THIS SHOW. YOU GUYS MUST GO AND WATCH STATION 19. THATS A GOOD TV SHOW.