12 reviews
Some left-wing people would have us, French citizens, think that revolutionaries were saints and that French History began in 1789. This movie reminds us that all was not black and white, and that there were heroes, and bad people and good people, in both camps, royalists and catholics as well as revolutionaries.
I don't know how much of Charette's private history is known to historians so I would call this movie a biopic rather than a documentary. And this movie was first meant for television before making it to the screen, so maybe it will disappoint the cinema viewer. However, I didn't find it without merit and ambition compared to the usual french comedies and societal movies. And I should say that the viewers' rating in France goes far above the critics' rating and the movie was applauded when I went to see it.
So... give it a try and make your own opinion.
I don't know how much of Charette's private history is known to historians so I would call this movie a biopic rather than a documentary. And this movie was first meant for television before making it to the screen, so maybe it will disappoint the cinema viewer. However, I didn't find it without merit and ambition compared to the usual french comedies and societal movies. And I should say that the viewers' rating in France goes far above the critics' rating and the movie was applauded when I went to see it.
So... give it a try and make your own opinion.
This film really looks stunning. In terms of art direction and realism, French films are superior to the plastic junk from Hollywood. However, if Vaincre ou Mourir had listened to one well-known American maxim: 'Show, don't tell', the film would have succeeded. Unfortunately, viewers are not allowed to experience history, we must listen to it and understand it.
The fact that at the beginning of the film a number of specialists start to indicate what is yet to come, does not bode well. We are then presented with a number of colorful characters. Unfortunately we are not allowed to get to know them, but they are explained and that is a killer for any drama.
Many films that tell an unexposed part of history have an enormous need for framing and interpretation. The result is a story that limps on two legs, in which facts are more important than drama. And let it be precisely drama that ensures that facts stick. There were probably too many correct or educational captains on the ship of this production. A good screenplay and a good director would have sufficed.
The fact that at the beginning of the film a number of specialists start to indicate what is yet to come, does not bode well. We are then presented with a number of colorful characters. Unfortunately we are not allowed to get to know them, but they are explained and that is a killer for any drama.
Many films that tell an unexposed part of history have an enormous need for framing and interpretation. The result is a story that limps on two legs, in which facts are more important than drama. And let it be precisely drama that ensures that facts stick. There were probably too many correct or educational captains on the ship of this production. A good screenplay and a good director would have sufficed.
- gekkepoppetje
- Apr 19, 2024
- Permalink
It may seem ankward from time to time, but this movie tells the story of an army lead by a true hero an army whose destiny is to be beaten, smashed, an army which fate was to lose. I have always been in love with such plots. Plots in the BRAVEHEART scheme but with less budget and such a dedication in terms of production design, care in directing. However this story was produced by LE PUY DU FOU, some producing firm whose DNA, spirit, soul is entirely dedicated to the "ideas" of those warriors of the late 1790's.... So the point of view may be realistic, no doubt, but not that factual, the Revolutionary troops are shown as evil and the Royalists - our heroes - the good guys. Because the good guys here were FOR THE KING; the total contrary to what we could have expected....and that's precisely for this reason that this movie is really worth watching. Remember BRAVEHEART, ROBIN AND MARIAN, Luc Besson's JEANNE D'ARC. It is a shame that this feature was not longer. If you like this war in Vendée, you also can try CHOUANS, from 1988. I would have prefered this awesome film produced by Gaumont, then it could have been impartial and just, but LE PUY DU FOU.... The same as if Poutine produced a film about war in Ukraine; I doubt that the Ukrainians would be shown as victims...But that doesn't mean that the Republican troops in the 1790's did not commit atrocities against civilians and populations.... But from Gaumont production, that would have been more believable.
- searchanddestroy-1
- Jul 25, 2023
- Permalink
Despite a high budget, the film has no film but its name. Most of the narration is read or written to us in long boxes, a film is made to show us, it is not an audio book. As for the rest, the image is jerky and the actions fragile and cowardly. There are moments clearly without any interaction between the characters, whether verbal or non-verbal the music let's not even talk about it, the costumes are there only positive value of the film, but to see beautiful costumes I prefer to go to a reproduction. On top of that, the director decided to choose a proselytizing film distributor, which meant that they only managed to distribute it in a few theaters. In addition during my viewing, many people were screaming "death to leftists" or other atrocities in the genre, be careful when leaving the room. Moreover, the film claims to be historic, but it is to the history of France what the Lord of the Rings is to the history of New Zealand. I had a better time in front of "Tirailleurs" which is really historic for once.
- pierrickvoltolini
- Feb 1, 2023
- Permalink
I have always believed that those who fought for freedom were the French revolutionaries, not the rebels in favor of absolutism and fanaticism. Good way to fool people. It is a sectarian film, in which the rebels, who do not accept the motto "liberty, equality and fraternity", are very good and the republicans are bad, cruel and perverse. The History of the French Revolution is thus disdained, since there is only a desire to glorify and exalt those who fought against it. The director of the film has not dealt at all with the importance that it had for France to achieve the end of feudalism and absolutism, in short, the authentic fight for freedom. Seen in the Spanish version, the accent with which a Frenchman speaks in his own country is also very shocking.
- lfpizarroruiz
- Jan 15, 2024
- Permalink
I know I have used that before - though I reckon I do like Her Story - more of a pun! Speaking of which - no pun intended of course. I did not know of this man and the story the movie is telling us. Everyone knows about Napoleon and other people (though even with them I doubt many know all the details - movie knowledge aside), but if you are not French (and even then) you will get a "new" story here.
I quite like the setting (time period, clothing/costumes and so forth), the action ... and it is always nice to root for the "little man" (not Napoleon in this case - sorry not sorry). So if you care about history (and his story), you will enjoy this either way. But if you like costume movies in general and don't care much about that ... you still will have a good time ... well you know what I mean ... the inevitable end will come as with every movie (well not literally) ...
I quite like the setting (time period, clothing/costumes and so forth), the action ... and it is always nice to root for the "little man" (not Napoleon in this case - sorry not sorry). So if you care about history (and his story), you will enjoy this either way. But if you like costume movies in general and don't care much about that ... you still will have a good time ... well you know what I mean ... the inevitable end will come as with every movie (well not literally) ...
French cinema tends to be the same theme over and over again. Here however it is a topic hardly ever mentioned and just for that it makes the film worth watching.
Now personally I found the first half of the film extremely hard to watch as we are shown the atrocities of the war, the barely armed peasants sent to be slaughtered by the 'hero' of the film. Then there is the counter attack where non fighters (elders, children and women) get slaughtered and we know it happened.
We mostly follow the side of the Vendeans at a time period called "the Terror" for how people in the same side would cut the heads off their former ally and now rivals, at a time revolutionaries were trying to fight most of Europe with under trained people through sheer numbers. Needless to say the resistance from the Vendeans was not appreciated and the 'solution' to it, as shown in the film, was brutal and merciless.
Be aware it is not a feel good film, it's about dark times and the film shows that well.
I strongly suggest people to watch the film to make their own opinions since many critics put it down for choosing a different topic or being done by a studio which is not vetted by established French studios.
Now personally I found the first half of the film extremely hard to watch as we are shown the atrocities of the war, the barely armed peasants sent to be slaughtered by the 'hero' of the film. Then there is the counter attack where non fighters (elders, children and women) get slaughtered and we know it happened.
We mostly follow the side of the Vendeans at a time period called "the Terror" for how people in the same side would cut the heads off their former ally and now rivals, at a time revolutionaries were trying to fight most of Europe with under trained people through sheer numbers. Needless to say the resistance from the Vendeans was not appreciated and the 'solution' to it, as shown in the film, was brutal and merciless.
Be aware it is not a feel good film, it's about dark times and the film shows that well.
I strongly suggest people to watch the film to make their own opinions since many critics put it down for choosing a different topic or being done by a studio which is not vetted by established French studios.
I've been deeply moved by this movie.
I only recently discovered what happened in Vendée, a french department, right after the revolution.
And it's important that peace can be made with this dark event of french history.
This is not about promoting kingdom over republic... Those reviews judging this movie by this angle are deeply wrong.
It's about loyalty and "panache" among many other qualities. The main character is fighting for a noble cause and has to cope with loyalty and treason from both sides.
And let's be honest, it might not be a blockbuster with famous actors or tremendous budget but, man, it has a story to tell and you can feel the spirit of these actors playing their role.
Deep respect.
I wish I could definitely see more movies like this and particularly with my kids.
I only recently discovered what happened in Vendée, a french department, right after the revolution.
And it's important that peace can be made with this dark event of french history.
This is not about promoting kingdom over republic... Those reviews judging this movie by this angle are deeply wrong.
It's about loyalty and "panache" among many other qualities. The main character is fighting for a noble cause and has to cope with loyalty and treason from both sides.
And let's be honest, it might not be a blockbuster with famous actors or tremendous budget but, man, it has a story to tell and you can feel the spirit of these actors playing their role.
Deep respect.
I wish I could definitely see more movies like this and particularly with my kids.
- denisvarlet
- Feb 6, 2023
- Permalink
A beautiful movie for a low-budget film shot in just 18 days!
A big unexpected success in France
A film about a very sad part of the history of France that the french republic has always sought to conceal.
Go and watch it, so that the massacre of hundreds of thousands of Vendeans will not be forgotten in the face of a republic which organized a real genocide (which is tried to be hidden...)
I hope that this theme will be discussed again because this period of history should not be forgotten.
Many other great Vendée generals also deserve a film about their history.
We will not forget all those who fought to defend their king, their religion and their freedom against the barbarism of the republic.
A big unexpected success in France
A film about a very sad part of the history of France that the french republic has always sought to conceal.
Go and watch it, so that the massacre of hundreds of thousands of Vendeans will not be forgotten in the face of a republic which organized a real genocide (which is tried to be hidden...)
I hope that this theme will be discussed again because this period of history should not be forgotten.
Many other great Vendée generals also deserve a film about their history.
We will not forget all those who fought to defend their king, their religion and their freedom against the barbarism of the republic.
- marcchavane
- Feb 5, 2023
- Permalink
Vaincre ou Mourir is a unique and captivating project from Puy du Fou Films, who launched it as their first production with a remarkable low 5 million euro budget and no public money contrary to the totality of the other French cinematographic productions. Despite the lack of press and media attention, it achieved great success, becoming one of the top box office films of the year and amassing over 300,000 admissions. The movie is a powerful retelling of François-Athanase Charette de La Contrie's extraordinary journey during the Vendée War, combining beautiful visuals, a dramatic score, and an emotionally engaging narrative for an immersive experience. Rod Paradot stars as Charette, a figure of great perseverance, as viewers are taken through his struggles and his commitment to his path and convictions. While there is some over-the-top dialogue, Vaincre ou Mourir succeeds in capturing the spirit of history and the resilience of the people of the Vendée region. It was a great success, though unfortunately not all cinema networks were keen to show it, because of the subject of the Vendéen genocide orchestrated by the idols of the French left.
Two potential criticisms of this documentary include the limited number of extras, which requires the camera to use close shots, and the prominence of the voice-over by Charette.
It is worth noting that the filmmakers consulted different historians with varying opinions, rather than just using the title of historian to legitimize the film without taking their perspectives into account.
Two potential criticisms of this documentary include the limited number of extras, which requires the camera to use close shots, and the prominence of the voice-over by Charette.
It is worth noting that the filmmakers consulted different historians with varying opinions, rather than just using the title of historian to legitimize the film without taking their perspectives into account.
- florian-03008
- Mar 14, 2023
- Permalink
An amazing movie. In France the movie industry is hugely the results of a leftist propaganda resulting in really bad movies. Nobody really cares about the French cinema for several decades now, but here we go. Fantastic actors, true story, hidden to the French People for so many decades. It is joyful to finally get such a great moment of art. The entire French critics got insane when this movie was release and the entire press went 100% when for the public it was as a fantastic moment of real French grandeur. My 3 kids loved it, an occasion to revisit the bloody French history and the terrible propaganda we, French People, got sunken into from our childhood.
Vaincre ou Mourir is an incredible piece of art
It's got incredible storytelling, a charismatic main lead, amazing shots, breathtaking sets. All with a relatively low budget of 5 million euro.
The movie tells the story of François-Athanase de Charette de la Contrie, a young lieutenant in the French Royal Navy.
As French revolution begins, he quits the navy and returns home. His peace doesn't last long as local peasants ask him to become their leader to rise up against the revolutionary army.
Reluctantly he agrees and promises to return "dead or victorious". Thus begins his journey in the Vendee wars which made him one of the most revered figure in the region.
The film touches on controversial topic, which goes against mainstream narrative in France. It was either attacked or ignored by media but became a huge success nonetheless.
I recommend it to everyone who wants to see the untold story of the Vendee uprising.
The movie tells the story of François-Athanase de Charette de la Contrie, a young lieutenant in the French Royal Navy.
As French revolution begins, he quits the navy and returns home. His peace doesn't last long as local peasants ask him to become their leader to rise up against the revolutionary army.
Reluctantly he agrees and promises to return "dead or victorious". Thus begins his journey in the Vendee wars which made him one of the most revered figure in the region.
The film touches on controversial topic, which goes against mainstream narrative in France. It was either attacked or ignored by media but became a huge success nonetheless.
I recommend it to everyone who wants to see the untold story of the Vendee uprising.
- krzysztofbartczak
- Sep 3, 2024
- Permalink