Narrator (26 episodes, 2022-2023)
Self (7 episodes, 2022-2023)
Self (6 episodes, 2023)
Self (5 episodes, 2022-2023)
Bill McLaughlin / Detective Sumpter / Pastor David Love / Peter / Police Officer (5 episodes, 2022-2023)
Self (5 episodes, 2023)
Investigator / Judge / Police Officer / She (4 episodes, 2022-2023)
Bob the oil man / David Weaver / Emmett County Sheriff Deputy / Todd Chance (4 episodes, 2022-2023)
Georgia Thompson / Taylor Wright / Teresa Stone / Tracy Fortson (4 episodes, 2022-2023)
Johnny Hubbard / Judge Flowers / Nathaniel Schoffer (3 episodes, 2022-2023)
Self (3 episodes, 2022-2023)
Dr. John Pitman / Justin Goodwin / Trenton Mallory (3 episodes, 2022-2023)
Michael Roberts / Officer Levy / Police Officer (3 episodes, 2022-2023)
Self (3 episodes, 2023)
Colton Pitonyak / Detective #1 / Jeremy Simko (3 episodes, 2023)
Inspector James / Steven (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Detective Jimenez / Jimmy Joste (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Rhonda Glover / Robin (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Roger Perry (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Carl Kopenkoskey / Tess Koster's Husband (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
David Estrada / Dustin Wehde (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Darlene Gentry (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Eric's Sister / Janet (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Investigator / Officer Wright (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Bert Richter / Youngest Son (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Detective Fugitt / JD (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Edith / Ruthanne Lodato (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Deputy Bruscher / Texas Ranger (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Barbara Weaver / Jennifer Cave (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Andrew Urdiales (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Inspector James / Steven, Robin's Dad (2 episodes, 2022-2023)
Detective #1 / Lyle Kopenkoskey (2 episodes, 2022)
Self (2 episodes, 2022)
Ed Fonder / Jack Despain (2 episodes, 2022)
Officer Laveaux / Police Officer (2 episodes, 2022)
Liz Marinello / Rhonda Smith (2 episodes, 2022)
Detective / Vince Marinello (2 episodes, 2022)
Ashley McArthur / Elizabeth (2 episodes, 2022)
Joe Kirby / Police Officer (2 episodes, 2023)
Jennifer Asbenson / Jessica Chance (2 episodes, 2023)
Detective #2 / Fred Andros (2 episodes, 2023)
Self (2 episodes, 2023)
Teresa Stone / Tracy Fortson (2 episodes, 2023)
Detective / Officer Short (2 episodes, 2023)
Kim Love / Susan Fassett (2 episodes, 2023)
Jeanmarie Becker / Nanette Johntson (2 episodes, 2023)
(1 episode, 2022)
Robert (Gun Shop Clerk) (1 episode, 2022)
Detective Harris (1 episode, 2022)
Roger Carroll (1 episode, 2022)
Self (1 episode, 2022)
Detective (1 episode, 2022)
Terrance Barker (1 episode, 2022)
Keith Gentry (1 episode, 2022)
Bonnie Woodward (1 episode, 2022)
Heather Woodward (1 episode, 2022)
Cassandra Waller (1 episode, 2022)
Detective O'Neill (1 episode, 2022)
Darlene (1 episode, 2022)
Michael Dojaquez (1 episode, 2022)
Samuel Dieteman (1 episode, 2022)
Barbara Raber (1 episode, 2022)
Detective Luke (1 episode, 2022)
Officer Jones (1 episode, 2022)
Jackie (1 episode, 2022)
Katrina Ben (1 episode, 2022)
Gary Wilmurth (1 episode, 2022)
Weaver's Son (1 episode, 2022)
Amber Smith (1 episode, 2022)
Eli Weaver (1 episode, 2022)
Mary-Jane Fonder (1 episode, 2022)
Monica Carroll (1 episode, 2022)
Carl Kelley (1 episode, 2022)
Eli Curiel (1 episode, 2022)
Zach McArthur (1 episode, 2022)
Mary (1 episode, 2022)
Carol Kopenkoskey (1 episode, 2022)
Amber Lynn (1 episode, 2022)
Neighbour (1 episode, 2022)
Barbara Weaver (1 episode, 2022)
Eric Somuah (1 episode, 2022)
Dale Hausner (1 episode, 2022)
Michelle Despain (1 episode, 2022)
Pastor Shreaves (1 episode, 2022)
Nathan Carroll (1 episode, 2022)
Marc Despain (1 episode, 2022)
Carrie Williams (1 episode, 2023)
Lead Investigator (1 episode, 2023)
Detective Weaver (1 episode, 2023)
Larry Bridges (1 episode, 2023)
Self (1 episode, 2023)
Sheriff (1 episode, 2023)
Police Officer (1 episode, 2023)
Lois Riess (1 episode, 2023)
Sharon Cave (1 episode, 2023)
Sammy (1 episode, 2023)
Detective Brown (1 episode, 2023)
Jason Fassett (1 episode, 2023)
Detective Rosewaren (1 episode, 2023)
Pamela Hutchinson (1 episode, 2023)
Dave Riess (1 episode, 2023)
Jenea Chance (1 episode, 2023)
Cassandra Corum (1 episode, 2023)
Julene Simko (1 episode, 2023)
Charles Severence (1 episode, 2023)
Doug Benton (1 episode, 2023)
Ron Kirby (1 episode, 2023)
Tracey Richter (1 episode, 2023)
Dawn Silvernail (1 episode, 2023)
(1 episode, 2023)
Stephanie McFarland (1 episode, 2023)
Jeff Fassett (1 episode, 2023)
Detective Salvatore (1 episode, 2023)
Eric Naposki (1 episode, 2023)
DCI Agent Vileta (1 episode, 2023)
Jane Laut (1 episode, 2023)
Randy Stone (1 episode, 2023)
Tess Koster (1 episode, 2023)
Detective (1 episode, 2023)
Colton Pitonyak (1 episode, 2023)
Todd Chance's Father (1 episode, 2023)
Officer Reinheimer (1 episode, 2023)
Brad executive assistant (1 episode, 2023)
Detective Snell (1 episode, 2023)
Nancy Dunning (1 episode, 2023)
Dave Laut (1 episode, 2023)