Alyson Hannigan credited as playing...
Lily Aldrin
- Ted Mosby: I can't decide. They're both awesome.
- Robin Scherbatsky: If only architects had two balls, right, Ted?
- [Ted gives her an annoyed look]
- Lily Aldrin: [Helpful] I got this. Ted,
- [extends fists]
- Lily Aldrin: left or right?
- Ted Mosby: Yes, yes, great idea. Let the fates decide, huh?
- [speaks while alternating fists]
- Ted Mosby: I will pick left.
- [Lily slaps him]
- Lily Aldrin: Just call one of 'em!
- Lily Aldrin: Wait a minute. You're going to date two girls at once? Don't you think you should just choose one before it gets serious?
- Ted Mosby: Define serious.
- Lily Aldrin: Well that's complicated. I guess you have to weigh expectations, emotional investments...
- Marshall Eriksen: Third base, serious at third base!