Thomas Middleditch credited as playing...
Duncan
- [the kids find themselves living inside of the old slasher movie that they were watching]
- Duncan: Okay. So, we're in the movie.
- Max Cartwright: Uh-huh. How do we get out of here?
- Gertie Michaels: Yeah, I like that question. That is a really, really good question. Duncan, can you answer that question, please?
- Duncan: What are you talking about? It's 1986! Our homes don't exist yet, they're probably just landfills waiting to be turned into crappy subdivisions. WE don't exist yet. I know for a fact my parents haven't met because I was an unplanned child.
- Duncan: I wonder if all this blood is just corn syrup, you know? Like these characters are walking around with just corn syrup in their veins. You know? Let's give it a shot here.
- [Duncan rubs blood from Mimi's corpse and licks his finger]
- Duncan: Oh, God. No, that is, um... That is not corn syrup. That is... Oh God, that's blood.
- Vicki Summers: I am glad that you die!
- Kurt: What?
- Duncan: Nothing! What she meant to say was that we all die eventually. Technically, we start dying the moment we're born.
- Duncan: The Bathematicians were so excited when I told them that Amanda Cartwright's daughter was my sister's best friend.
- Gertie Michaels: Stepsister.
- Duncan: Why would you say that? That's so hurtful.
- Chris Briggs: What are Bathematicians?
- Duncan: Camp Bloodbath fans. It's kind of our awesome nickname.
- Gertie Michaels: Did you know that a nickname immediately becomes uncool when you give it to yourself?
- Duncan: If this is a dream, then there's a very strong chance that my dad's gonna come up to us naked and offer us some pecan pie. But don't take any. It is not pecan pie!
- Duncan: Camp Bloodbath is like the granddaddy of all campsite slasher films, okay. Amazing production design, insane music, over-the-top acting. It's a cult classic!