Rita Slayton
Megan Slayton
Joe Booker
Pastor Carl Slayton
Tony Rowe
Larissa 'Schottsie' Booker (as Heather D. Amos)
Det. Lt. Frank Beltrane
Colleen DeRidder (as Kate Cloutier)
Julie Booker
Det. Diane Ripley
Roxy
Officer Jill Benge
Ellie Mae
Number 25 (as Theresa Anne Stecker)
Number 24
Number 26
Number 27 (as Sarah Burgduff)
Jerry
Woman on TV
Baby Megan Slayton (archive footage)
Church Congregation (as Mary M. Caruso)
Church Congregation
DannyBoy