In a nostalgic-feeling '90s/ 2000's inspired rom-com, EVE and IVY are both looking for true love and have resorted to manifesting with the full moon that their crushes MATT and BEN fall in love with them. However, in their manifesting, the girls aren't specific in indicating which Matt or Ben they're after, and causing every Matt and Ben in their proximity to fall in love with them, creating chaos for the girls. Eve and Ivy dodge multiple love confessions as they try to figure out what's going on, and one of the girls realizes that the love received as a result of the manifestations isn't real. She tries to get the other to come to the same conclusion, but she must decide for herself if she will continue to pursue straightforward, 'surface-level' love, or if she wants to find something deeper.