Peter Pan
Wendy Darling
Captain Hook
Tiger Lily
Smee
John Darling
Michael Darling
Mrs. Darling
Mr. Darling
Tinker Bell
Curly
Nibs
Slightly
Tootles
Twin 1
Twin 2
Birdie
Bellweather
Bill Jukes
Gurley
Sallyport
Old Clemson
Skylight
Mermaid
Adult Wendy
Older Wendy
Mrs Starkey
Scrimshaw Sam
Dirtbag Benny
Tiger Lily's Grandmother
Pirate Chorus Member
Pirate Chorus Member (as Tony Kazoleas)
Gundeck Pirate
Jolly Roger Pirate
Jolly Roger Pirate / Gangly Pirate
Jolly Roger Pirate (as Josh Mazerolle)
Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate
Skull Rock Pirate
Peter's Shadow
Hook's Shadow
Black Matthew (uncredited)
Jolly Roger Old Fiddler Pirate (uncredited)
Puppeteer (uncredited)
Pirate Crew Member (uncredited)
Pirate (uncredited)
Children's Choir Ensemble (uncredited)
Pirate Crew Member #1 (uncredited)
Pirate #22 (uncredited)