Lucy Preston
Wyatt Logan
Rufus Carlin
Connor Mason
Denise Christopher
Jiya
Garcia Flynn
Bass Reeves
Emma Whitmore
Grant Johnson
Jesse James
Amy Preston
Robert Ford
Charles Ford
Marshal Hoffman
Marshal Greer
Wes Gillman
Seth
George Reeves
Nellie (as Kimberley Ndlovu)
Saloon Waitress
Town Reporter
Townsfolk (uncredited)
Townie Patron (uncredited)