Joe Goldberg
Love Quinn
Ellie Alves
Forty Quinn
Candace Stone (credit only)
Delilah Alves
Will
Henderson
Lucy
Sunrise Darshan Cummings
Calvin
Tina
Jonah
Freddy
Improv Dude Andy
Sally
Improv Nerd (as Joel Wiersema)
Mark
Jake
Beth
Nina
Sarah
Geoff
Candle (uncredited)
Improve Troupe Member (uncredited)
Partygoer (uncredited)