It's ok in my book. Ok, I'm just gonna start off by saying that a lot of people here that "anaylze" a film are just trying to make themselves sound "holier-than-thou".
What is it that makes a film good? Personally, I enjoyed this, along The Green Mile, and the what could possibly be the new Citizen Kane of pictures, American Beauty.
True, this is a horror movie. So is it right there that we're supposed to treat this movie as though it has no redeeming value? A) The ending was very good. It was a "suprise". I find that most people who say the ending suck say it sucks because they couldn't figure it out =) I thyink that *was* intentional on the director's part. B) The acting was good. The character's filled their roles, and hey, not everything has to be overly dramatic indepth, and certainly the film would lose meaning if we had to know the ins and outs of every character in order for us to have "feelings" for them when they die. When a person dies so tragically it IS emotional because a life is being taken so a person can fulfill a petty vendetta.
That's just a few reason I find this movie good and I'm afraid I'll go over 1,000 words, so adios =)