Nip It In The Bud About half way through this thing, it hit me. Who does Billy Bob Thornton remind me of? Who is he doing? Barney! Barney Fife! As in 'nip it in the bud.' Skinny as a rail, dark protruding eyes and lips and completely inept. Living a life of quiet angst in a small, sleepy town with a lot of shade trees.
The newest film from those Coen Brothers, Joel and Ethan, via USA Films, has an awful title, `The Man Who Wasn't There,' starring chameleon, Billy Bob Thornton. This is his story, delivered in a monotone voice-over. Narration throughout a film usually means trouble, like they blinked 'cause they couldn't keep the plot together. Not this time. This film is all about trouble but it's not on the screen, it's bubbling just beneath the surface.
Billy Bob is Floyd the barber, no wait, he's Ed the barber telling us a tale of life in 1949 America when men wore hats and ties. Women wore hats too plus stocking with seams and their shoes matched their bags. Order out of chaos. It's very difficult to present the recent past accurately, don't fear, the Coens have done it again. The details of this modest-budget production are meticulous. And the details of the plot have more twists and turns than Highway One. Just enjoy the ride.
The dark themes are typical for a Joel-Ethan script and they are played for laughs; murder, adultery, embezzlement, aliens and the electric chair. Tee hee. And mercifully, no rock and roll. Only Beethoven, who hasn't been this scary since Clockwork Orange, me droogies.
Coen cohort, Roger Deakins shot this on color negative and printed it in black and white presenting images with all the uncomfortable elegance as Diane Arbus photo book. In a word, gorgeous. Deakins says they took visual inspiration from noir classics like Shadow of a Doubt and Double Indemnity but the soul of the film is strictly The Postman Always Rings Twice and the look and sound of it echoes Call Northside 777. The scenes with Tony Shaloub, mostly in silhouette, are very Citizen Kane.
The Coens love actors. Like a lot of directors, Joel C. is in love with his leading lady and puts the same actress in all his films. But unlike a lot of other directors, he's actually married to the woman and so far hasn't traded her in for a progressively younger version with each new effort. Someone please stop David Lynch.
Frances MacDormand is this film's femme fatale, Doris. Smoking, soaking, drunkenly swerving and sleeping it off. More gorgeous. And another Coen regular, Jon Polito (known also for Barry Levinson's TV Homicide) quietly owns the screen even when he's submerged. Other actors who primarily work on the small screen, Michael Badalucco (ABC's The Practice) and James Gandolfini (HBO's The Sopranos) shine like silver.
Again, this is Ed's story and it's a ghost story, that's why the man isn't there. But what is there is great. I can just hear Andy now. 'You beat everything, Barney, d'you know that? You just beat everything.'