A COMPLETE UNKNOWN (2024) James Mangold delivers good vibes with A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. Vibrations are important in any music bio-pic, but doubly so when the subject is Bob Dylan who's life and career has been so thoroughly documented and (some would say, including Dylan himself) over-analyzed. The script is based on Elijah Wald's book Dylan Goes Electric!
Mangold (and co-writer Jay Cocks) smartly focus on Dylan's rise in the early to mid-60s. They set the folk music backdrop pretty well positing Woody Guthrie (Scoot McNairy) as the movement's spiritual grandfather, Pete Seeger (an excellent Edward Norton) as the father and Dylan (Timothy Chalamet) as the prodigal son. It's a bit contrived, but works for the purpose here. Some of the signposts (the JFK assassination, the Cuban Missile Crisis etc.) are a bit too on the nose. Dylan's rocky relationships with Sylvie Russo (Elle Fanning; "Russo" being a pseudonym for Suze Rotolo - per Dylan's personal request) and, especially with cohort and collaborator Joan Baez (Monica Barbara, also very good) are decently depicted. Trying to decipher who Bob Dylan really is, presents more of an issue as his 'character' morphed many times over the decades beginning with dispatching his childhood as "Robert Zimmerman". Dylan's statements are more questions than answers, seemingly in the process of creating riddles and mythology on a daily basis.
It's all about the music. The cast also includes Boyd Holbrook as Johnny Cash (who, in his way showed Dylan than one can crossover genres), and they all do a fine job of making it all look and feel authentic to the artists involved. There's a pop and spring to the performance sequences which energize the movie.
Even when they sound 'different' from the well known versions, one never questions their veracity. That's the irony here. Many film bios on musicians feel phony when the actors open their mouths and strum their instruments. A COMPLETE UNKNOWN is the opposite. The music is credible, it's the dialogue scenes where it's sometimes tone deaf. The actors are good, but the script is full of predictable cliches and platitudes, which also hampers Chalamet's otherwise solid performance. At times, one feels like exhorting: Shut up and play yer guitar! It's historically pretty accurate save for the most important scene - the climactic 1965 Newport Folk Festival - which is riddled with distortions. Rotolo/Russo wasn't there, and neither was Cash. The near riotous booing was minor compared to an earlier show in England. Seeger didn't really threaten to take an axe to the sound system etc. Etc.. No, this isn't a documentary, but, as noted at the outset, this stuff is so well documented that Mangold simply strays too far. It's not a fatal blow, but it's still an unforced error.
A COMPLETE UNKNOWN, wobbly script and all, is still a very enjoyable ride that captures the feeling of Dylan and the music world at the time with exceptional art direction and costuming. The actors should all take a bow for how well they studied and rehearsed their musical chops. Mangold deserves credit for selecting and help shape their performances. The vibe is solid.