Three's company meets the X-Files To be blunt: good premise, so-so script, bad acting. In the end, it uses soft lighting and emotional situations to try and cover for a marginal script, one-dimensional characters and, again, very poor acting.
Not sure if the writers and producers were given the green light on this to be a summer pilot/series with only two weeks to produce the first episode, but wow is there some bad acting here. First and foremost is "little brother." I won't bore you with all the qualities that preclude him from being even a marginally good actor, suffice it to say you just know the instant he opened his mouth after running out of the bathroom....he's bad. Yes, I gave him the benefit of the doubt and watched longer, but it just got worse.
"Hapless dad" started off OK, until I realized, during the dinner scene, he overacts. And overacts...and overacts. Wait! It makes sense - like father character, like son character.
Finally, "attractive psychologist, social service worker, loving mother....aging beach bum" does not sell me here - where is the intelligence required for a character of this supposed depth and dimension? Oh, wait! Let's not forget the stereotypical, over the top, snob neighbor.
Or the bumbling neurosurgeons who, when faced with the questioning of an obnoxious 12-year old, reconsider their entire theory about Kyle's condition? Is this a sitcom, or a drama? How many script writers does it take to kill a good premise? In the words of 'Party-goer #3': "Oh snap! Did you see that?!" Yes, yes, I did. And it was not good.
To me, this is Three's Company meets the X-files. Either they need to lock it up FAST and let this story live up to its potential, or it will be the shadow of a memory of a TV show, faster than Manimal, the Lone Gunmen and Ferris Bueller.