With only a few exceptions, most things were downgrades Caught an advance screening, and 3/4 of the people around me agreed - it was just ok, but not good. NO HATE, but 90% was a downgrade from the original complex and multilayered material where everyone, down to cast with just one line, delivered absolute STAR power. In 20 years since that original, a lot has evolved within the high school arena, so production naturally had to tweak some things to make it work. Some of it works, much doesn't.
Judging on its own merits, I feel it simply would work better on a stage, and that the biggest fault lied with Casting, who hired *singers* who needed more time with acting coaches. I'd probably like it in a stage setting. BUT, this is the silver screen - and the magnifying glass is much less forgiving.
The biggest offender for me - and seriously NO HATE because she seems super lovely and may just be better suited in other things - was Karen. Every moment with her was eyeroll inducing. The acting was actual amateur high school production level (at best) cliche ditz caricature with zero nuance. Gretchen lacked any energy or drive, or that absolutely obsessive DESPERATE need to be needed by her queen - she was instead very pedestrian. Not a member of the queens herself but just a follower. And that Queen (Regina) didn't give me the level of commanding stone cold respect and fear in the student body like the OG did. While the actress is very beautiful and talented, she didn't deliver on the respect-demanding queen bee of the school for me. It felt like a Nickelodeon show or something. The trio all fell so flat - they weren't QUEENS of the school who everyone bowed down down to and lived in fear of, they're actually just the wannabe girls who would have worshipped and aspired TO BE that original trio.
I truly didn't understand the change of Jingle Bell Rock at all and how the school was so quickly able to turn on Regina when she essentially suffers an actual big accident on stage and people are then essentially posting upskirt vid of it. Baffling and unrealistic. Hit by a bus is the bar to be deserving of pity but not the stage mishap? Uhhok. Damien's song choice change however? Hilarious. Getting diarrhea on a Ferris wheel is way too extreme and actually mortifying vs the previous nuanced "at Barnes and Noble" where it would be just embarrassing for the character knowing her friends knew. The difference between overly dramatic teen girls and everyone in real life. Overshot on that one. And while Tina and Tim being in a relationship is a fun evolution on their flirty repartee in the original, Ms Norbury's divorce and life-in-shambles aspect brought a lot in to the character. Although hilarious, she's more one-dimensional now.
I'm sorry but Aaron Samuels is supposed to be *h-o-t-t* and he's just a regular guy. There's no context to make him so desired by the Queen of the school and it makes no sense. It's like the character of Guy in Never Been Kissed - the movie wants us to believe he's a heartthrob but doesn't give us the goods to do so. Why casting was so forgiving when he doesn't even bring singing talent leaves me scratching my head. And Busy Philipps, who I normally enjoy, felt like a one-dimensional cardboard cutout of the role that Amy Poehler gave so many layers to, a total tour de force and showstealer.
Damien and Janis were fine actors and good singers, though I would have liked them to feel like more of outcasts. Janis was punk and glam and fierce, not a social outcast. With this generation being more accepting of alternative lifestyles and less inclined to outright bully and ostracize, I understand how that presented a challenge to the filmmakers, but they didn't deliver at accomplishing it, and I feel thats integral to the story.
NOW, for the GOOD, Cady had excellent energy and played her role well in both acting and singing. Grand slam there. Tina Fey was effective at changing Ms Norbury enough to keep it fresh, while allowing for things that were omitted to not be mourned - bravo! The bit like she was about to break into song but was just clearing her throat was a riot. I also really appreciated this slightly elevated version of Regina post-accident. Being drugged up and having a resolution wth Cady and being loopy at the Spring Fling was a fresh and funny take. And obviously, it was great to see the cameos and Easter eggs- Lindsay saying this has only happened once before, the cutout tanktop brief flash, etc.
Obviously, with more negative takes than positive, I understand people won't be happy or agree with my assessment, but it's just the reality of how I felt. NO hate towards this very vocally talented cast, I wish them all the best in their future works!!! But I don't feel any need to revisit this one. It turns out, the limit does, in fact, exist - and it's just 1. But decide for yourself.