Spielberg brings magic on the screen! I'm really not the type for musicals. Music is one of my favorite elements in films, but if the characters start singing every five minutes, I often get bored very quickly. That's why I had my reservations before Steven Spielberg's new film adaptation West Side Story. I hadn't seen the original 1961 film and therefore went in without any prior knowledge. To what extent that influenced my experience is hard to say. But it wouldn't be a Spielberg film if it had nothing special about it.
Without having seen the original (which won ten Oscars), I know this much from sources that the plot is more or less the same as its predecessor. For example, the film already begins with a dance sequence in which the core plot is established. Two New York gangs, the Jets and the Sharks, manned by Puerto Ricans, are fighting for supremacy in their neighborhood called West Side. Both cannot get along with each other and repeatedly get into brutal brawls until the police intervene, always clearly taking sides with the "locals" Jets. This leads to cultural conflicts, which are further polarized by the decisions of some gang members. The former leader of the Jets, Tony (Ansel Elgort), has actually come to terms with his past and wants to start a new life. His loyalty to the Jets, however, still endures. One evening he meets the young Maria (Rachel Zegler) and they suddenly fall in love. Since Maria is the sister of the Shark leader Bernardo (David Alvarez), this constellation quickly leads to escalation between the two groups. Elgort and Zegler have moments when their chemistry is thoroughly electrifying, especially when they sing their duets. However, Elgort's acting clearly stinks against his female partner, which is why their scenes together usually seem discordant. This also hurts Zegler's performance, because although she does her job sensationally, she never really stands out. Others are responsible for that. For one, Ariana DeBose as Bernardo's girlfriend Anita. She is not only aesthetically a class stronger than all the others, but can shine especially in her mimic and sentimental scenes and tears the screen every time. The highlight for me was Mike Faist as Tony's right-hand man Riff, who delivers a very emotional performance and completely captivated me with his every move and vocal delivery. Rita Moreno (she was Anita in the original) is also worth watching as a mentor to all who don't want to take sides, although she unfortunately comes up a bit short until the end.
In terms of production, Spielberg has once again achieved a stroke of genius. I would even argue that West Side Story was his best directorial effort since Munich. The decision to rely exclusively on Broadway actors who know how to put themselves in the limelight was spot on. In terms of visual violence, too, the film is a real treat. Old New York, for all its deep ditches, had a certain flair, thanks to some great camerawork. I had an unexpectedly good time with West Side Story and, as a non-connoisseur, was thoroughly surprised and tangentially affected by the plot. It's a pity that I was almost out of it after the first thirty minutes because of the drawn-out sequels. But it's a good thing that the film then turns the corner and thrilled me. Besides, the film contains just the right mixture between song and dialogue!