This is a non Hollywood formula character study This is, in time going to be an example of one of those love or loathe films perhaps even reaching cult status. Despite an all star cast, a reputable Film Star/Director and initially a rather familiar plot, most mainstream seeking cinema-goers will be disappointed in the outcome. On the other hand it's an achievement to follow the Sean Penn/Jack Nicholson collaboration, The Crossing Guard, their previous effort, Penn proving himself as an effective filmmaker and Nicholson proving that he is an actor and not just a movie megastar.
It's the emotion, the loneliness, the obsession and the ever righteous attitude of Nicholson's character that drives the movie along at a slow pace yet managing to remain enthralling. Aaron Ekhart, Benecio Del Toro, Robin Wright Penn and Sam Shepherd add support alongside a slightly wasted list of cameo appearances including Vanessa Redgrave, Helen Mirren, Harry Dean Stanton and Mickey Rourke. Like Nicholson in the movie, as a viewer you seek satisfaction as he becomes more determined to find the truth and catch the culprit of a brutally murdered young girl, he always seems to be on the right track but you often question his intelligence...was this guy really a retired homicide detective?
Like many controversial thrillers the climax of the movie, which I won't go into will be talked about whenever the film comes up in conversation...are we satisfied? has justice been done?
This is a thought provoking film, beautifully shot despite it's grim subject matter but it's a safe bet that it won't break box office records, but staying clear of Hollywood's Good Guys and Bad Guys clichés this film does offer alternative originality.