Hate me, but this is amazing This was just a better Last Jedi Luke story. I agree that Luke's actions were rash, seeing as he is the embodiment of hope and the ending of Return of the Jedi left on a high note and not depressing. But Obi Wan? The man who ended his previous movie walking away from his best friend who was dying because of him? Please. This was more than expected behavior from him imo. I understand that people don't like their characters "digressing," because yes Obi Wan in this show was a bit off seeing how he was all skippy in episodes 3 and 4. And honestly we don't really get to see the effects of Anakin's battle with Obi Wan in Episode 3. I mean, In A New Hope he's a fun, strong, wise old man. We do get to see these effects during their Episode 3 battle, and it is heart wrenching, but after the battle he kinda just gets down to business with dispersing Luke and Leia and that's it. Events as big as that leave an impact. They leave scars. Sure, time does help heal wounds like these and it still would have made complete sense had this show not exist and A New Hope Obi Wan is his strong self, but this show is set in half the time between episodes 3 and 4. Maybe for some characters a terrible event can heal in that time, and I would completely understand if that were the case here, but it also makes total sense that Obi Wan is broken at the beginning of this show. He has been doing nothing with his life lol. It's not like he has anything to help him get over his trauma, especially since a lot of the Jedi are damn dead. And it doesn't help that Darth Vader, the literal embodiment of his failure, as he sees it, stalks him the whole show as a constant reminder of just how piss poor his old life was left off. I was skeptical too admittedly, but the show honestly did such an amazing job presenting his psyche. And the show builds upon this immensely. His journey throughout the show was believable. You can see his progress, and a lot of it is through Ewan's acting, which is phenomenal. By the time episode 4 and 5 time around you can start to see glimpse of the old, faithful Obi Wan. And when the final episode roles around...oh man.
Here are the rankings of each episode before I talk about spoilers:
Episode 1: 10/10
2: 10/10
3: 9/10
4: 8/10
5: 10/10
6: 10/10.
SPOILER TALK: Vader being a constant reminder of Obi Wan's failure, again, as he sees it, is so important to the emotion of this show. In the first few episodes, Obi Wan wants to run from his past. And seeing his past, that's understandable. Like I said, we last saw Obi wan as a broken man who had his whole life ripped apart. Him cowering before Vader in episode 3 shows us how traumatizing seeing him again is. He builds his hope back in the next episodes, a lot of it thanks to Leia who is awesome in this show, and finally faces his past in one of my favorite confrontations in the whole franchise. It really was an amazing rematch that was so earned. The dialogue was on point and captured every emotion, and included great callbacks lol. When Obi Wan tears up and finally reconciles with his past by telling Anakin he is sorry, I was destroyed dude. He finally gets to tell his brother how he truly feels and how he truly regrets what happened, which haunted him ever since. It was beautiful and heart breaking. And since Obi wan was able to express that, he can be free of his guilt and once again become the man he was with a new mission. A new hope.
The other characters in the show were great. Darth Vader I of course discussed and was great for those previously stated reason, but also was just badass overall. And I loved how the flashback tied into him and Obi Wan's approach in the episode. And I completely get why he let Obi wan run around all the time; he was waiting for a real challenge and for his old master to return so he can genuinely beat him. Also I love seeing Vader in his prime The Grand Inquisitor was cool but not as good as he was in Rebels, but that was simply for the fact that Vader overshadowed him lol Leia was a freaking doll and the way Obi Wan summed her up in the last episode was really how she was in the show, and how she is overall honestly. She was super accurate to how she was in the originals and seeing Alderaan and more of Bail and her mother really makes its destruction in episode 4 really sad. Reeva or whatever her name is, the third sister, is pretty great I think. Her backstory is super interesting actually and her motives are too. I really did enjoy her decision at the end of the series and honestly I don't think her surviving is a big deal or surprise. Tons of people survive saber strikes; I'm surprised people don't finish the damn job in this universe. And Qui Gon was a nice edition. I really hope there is a second season delving more into that.
So overall yeah I really loved this lol.