yes, it IS underrated, folks OK, I Spy is a completely formulaic buddy movie. There is not a single new situation in it.
BUT IT HAS OWEN WILSON, FOR GOD'S SAKE! A BIG non-formulaic element.This is not my libido talking. Owen Wilson is a genuinely funny and refreshingly unique star. He has a heck of a lot to contribute to a movie. This is the Oscar-nominated screenwriter who co-wrote the critically acclaimed and highly original films "Bottle Rocket," "Rushmore," and "The Royal Tenenbaums" with his buddy Wes Anderson.
In "I Spy" he is the lovable, droopy-lipped "doofus" who is not quite as dumb as he looks. He steals small sleek spy gadgets because his are gigantic and look like they come out of a "1972 Radio Shack" catalogue. Imagine James Bond going around with gadgets the size of water balloons! He has the hots for a fellow spy and is obsessed with going on a stakeout with her. He immediately puts it to his bosses that this new mission is a "classic stakeout scenario, right?" He won't let it go. Next is a SPOILER: Even when he realizes she is the bad guy he won't admit it. Murphy points out that she kept stabbing him in the thigh while trying to get some information. Wilson rubs it and says, "It doesn't hurt that bad....." Wilson is constantly and effortlessly knocking balls out of the park with his ad-libs.
I assume most people are avoiding this movie because of Eddie Murphy. It is understandable. This guy hasn't given a rat's behind about pleasing an audience since 1988 (unless you count "Nutty Professor"). He's even admitted it in interviews - ah, he doesn't care. He's made his money so he'll go on wasting our time.
Having said that, I have to admit Murphy is the best he has been in years. Yeah, a little too fast talking about nothing at times and if I had a dime for every time he says "I'm Kelly Robinson" I could probably do all my Xmas shopping. But that is the character - arrogant and pampered. There are instances of the old Eddie at times.
Oh, and is Malcolm McDowell in this movie? I saw Malcolm McDowell's face and I heard him open his mouth at times, but I'm still trying to reach a verdict on that. What a shame this once brilliant actor is forced to play these cardboard villain types.
But back to Wilson. I'm sorry that he didn't get top billing because it is he who makes I Spy worth watching. Without him, yes, it's crap. Studios need to face facts that Eddie Murphy is now box-office poison and can bring down or set back rising careers of stars. I just hope he hasn't set back too far the career of the guy who humbly took on the second banana role in this movie - we NEED Owen Wilson.
And I don't know where these bad reviews from audience members are coming from. I saw the movie twice because of Wilson and both times the audience loved it - because of his lines and expressions and, yes, even because of Murphy's few moments of old brilliance. There were almost non-stop laughs throughout the whole show. The Sexual Healing and "sewer" scenes had people bending over and kicking the seats in hysterics.
"I Spy" is not a masterpiece but it is not brainless. If you really watch it via the performance of Owen Wilson and drop all preconceived notions about Eddie Murphy you get a rather enjoyable viewing experience. When pictures headlining people like Vin Diesel are topping the box-office charts, it's a pity this one will sink into oblivion.