a very long experience with an overrated movie.... A movie with Tobey Maguire and this situated in the American civil war, was the snag that got me. I had to see this movie. The movie begins... A short introduction...OK, it plays in Missouri. Special problems with the North and South of Missouri and the German settlers. It seems to be interesting... Then the first awful thing: the time jumps in the beginning a year forward, and the audience doesn't know which time it is actually. I disliked it, and until the end i didn't know in which year it plays, because it jumps a lot in the time without one little date. For a historic movie, not really a good sign. The next bad thing is Tobey himself. He seems to practise for his next role in Wonderboys. This little psycho touch with the "i am not here attitude" and short sentences to speak, doesn't work out here. In the first minutes we have an action scene, in which Tobey looses one of his fingers. I think "nice" and i am now eager to see more, and i am waiting and waiting, to be very honest: i am still waiting. After this little action scene Tobey and his 3 companions are spending a lot of time in a hideaway in the wood. And the movie is getting longer and longer. Now we have to learn how stupid the war is with 3 little examples: First one: Tobey is a German, the other Southerners dislike Germans...... Second one: Jeffrey Wright plays the Afroamerican Daniel Holt, who is fighting with Southerners. (By the way, this Black-White racism, is getting more and more boring. This thing is exhausted, for sure in movies. Dear Americans, if you have to go on and on with this, take some other races, like Asians too.) And third thing are the letters from the enemy. Oh, who could have thought about it, they have the very same problems like we have.
OK, i've got the message: War is bad, and our heroes are between this insane thing....
Next action scene, and a short one, the farmers house got arsoned and Tobey shoots the perpetrators. Then we have the next action scene with an insane attack on Kansas City, in which the suspension is built up between Tobey and an evil crazy man. Now the audience is waiting for the result in this case. You think that there will be a last shoot out between the two, a nice action scene....And the end: Tobey invites his enemy in the wood for a tea...then he says him, he has to get out of here..... THE END A long stupid movie.....