Terrific Slowburn with Little Exposition I try to be careful with my 9s and 10s, as I want to reserve those ratings for movies I found truly great. After careful reflection, I decided this one deserves a 9.
It is a movie that moves slowly from scene to scene, and I would call it a slow-burn, but it does a good job of setting up the central tension immediately. It then moves the viewer along into a mystery that only partially unravels, attenuated by dramatic fighting scenes. The gorgeous scenery helps, but my attention was drawn intensely to the protagonist and his fate as he gets caught up with these ominous characters.
The critics are correct that many questions are left unanswered. If you don't like that in a movie, maybe this is not for you. They are not correct there is no story. There is a story and it's a good one.
I don't want to spoil it, but these plot points are established early on: Core (the protagonist) is peaceful nature. We know this from him talking about how it was difficult to kill even a dangerous wolf, and later it's confirmed by some of his actions. Vernon Sloane is a violent character. We see him killing people as soon as he is introduced. Medora is a mysterious character, with some forebodingly odd behavior from the get-go. Seeing Core getting mixed up with the Sloanes sets up wonderful tension, and it doesn't let up until the end.
I haven't read the book, and it's true the movie doesn't answer exactly what is going on with Vern and Medora. As a viewer, you don't need to know those details to appreciate the challenges, both moral and practical, facing Core. He doesn't know those details anyway, so the movie stays true to the 3rd person limited perspective it's mostly aiming for. That said, there are some clues in the conversations with Cheeon and the old woman shaman.
If you like a story with an interesting protagonist faced with some inscrutable people and tough dillemmas, but where everything will not necessarily be laid out for you, then I highly recommend this.