Great potential, but a directorial blunder... *****SPOILERS*****
I'll try to keep this short. I am one of the more discerning Trekkies, and I can hold my own with the nerdiest of Star Trek fans, but I still have a grip on reality and I am completely at ease in social situations...
But I am well aware of the continual TNG plot holes throughout the series and movies, yet I have learned to accept a certain artistic-license-filled-script-style over the course of the TNG storyline. I love the momentum of the character development over the years, and have come to love the Enterprise crew both professionally and personally.
That being said, I'd have to concede that "A Generation's Final Journey" is actually "A Generation's Flop Under A Director Who Has No Insight Into The True Spirit Of Star Trek." I read the reviews of Nemesis before seeing it, so I had some time to prepare for the possibility of a let-down. But I still had high hopes for its salvation, and viewed it without preconceptions. It was all for naught. Star Trek: Nemesis is the product of a great concept and the great evolving storyline of TNG clashing with a typical cliche-spewing, chase-scene-loving, explosion-happy, catch-phrase-driven, commercial Hollywood action director. Star Trek: Nemesis is actually that: Star Trek's Nemesis. It's your typical 21st century action movie. There were a few scenes where I thought I accidentally wandered into The Matrix theater.
I tried to love the last TNG theatrical installment, but with the off-road chase scene, the ship-flying-within-a-ship sequence, Data's free-form space flight, and the dismal time-wasting, thumb-twiddling final fight scene (not to mention the relaxed, meaningful gazes as the countdown rolls on towards ultimate destruction), I had to give up. Nemesis has a weak plot to begin with, but perhaps could have been salvaged through heartfelt style. Unfortunately, that didn't happen. For true Star Trek fans, Nemesis as a movie is a sadder situation than the death of Data. However, if you like the storyless, one-dimensional, catch-phrase-laden action flicks that Hollywood has been diligently churning out over the past several years, just set your TIVO to catch all the Bruce Willis flicks and NASCAR races on cable and run out and rent Nemesis. There are plenty of out-of-this-world physics and reality-defying action devices to keep you and your entire toothless trailer family happy for hours.
And the music? Hmmmm... Disturbing in and of itself. Not what you'd expect for a Star Trek film. That could be a refreshing concept under more normal circumstances, but it just turned out to be bizarre. Who knows what the hell Jerry Goldsmith was thinking with this one. At one point I could have sworn the crew was watching "The Young And The Restless" in the background. Perhaps another terrible suggestion from the Trek-spirit-less director.
One last thing: Having Data die is one doozie of a climax, but the calculated setup of the retarded older brother, B-4, (and his convenient transfer of all of Data's memory) negates any real impact that story turn could have had on the fans.
All in all, I forced myself to like Nemesis, but I think that's just nostalgia and longing taking over. Many reviewers equate Nemesis with Star Trek V, and I'd have to agree. It's the bastard brother that no one in the family wants to acknowledge. Oh well. There are always reruns...